Phillips Nicole M, Duke Maxine M, Weerasuriya Rona
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Faculty of Health, Deakin University, Geelong, Vic., Australia.
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Deakin University Centre for Quality and Patient Safety (QPS), Geelong, Vic., Australia.
J Clin Nurs. 2017 Dec;26(23-24):4344-4352. doi: 10.1111/jocn.13761. Epub 2017 Apr 20.
To report on a study investigating questioning skills of clinical facilitators who support the learning of undergraduate nursing students.
The ability to think critically is integral to decision-making and the provision of safe and quality patient care. Developing students' critical thinking skills is expected of those who supervise and facilitate student learning in the clinical setting. Models used to facilitate student learning in the clinical setting have changed over the years with clinicians having dual responsibility for patient care and facilitating student learning. Many of these nurses have no preparation for the educative role. This study adapted a comparative study conducted over fifteen years ago.
Descriptive online survey including three acute care patient scenarios involving an undergraduate nursing student. Participants were required to identify the questions they would ask the student in relation to the scenario.
A total of 133 clinical facilitators including clinical teachers, clinical educators and preceptors from five large partner healthcare organisations of one Australian university participated.
The majority of questions asked were knowledge questions, the lowest category in the cognitive domain requiring only simple recall of information. Facilitators who had undertaken an education-related course/workshop or formal qualification asked significantly more questions from the higher cognitive level.
The study provides some evidence that nursing facilitators in the clinical setting ask students predominantly low-level questions. Further research is needed to identify strategies that develop the capacity of facilitators to ask higher level cognitive questions.
Clinical facilitators should undertake targeted education that focuses on how to frame questions for students that demand application, analysis, synthesis and evaluation.
报告一项关于调查支持本科护理学生学习的临床指导教师提问技巧的研究。
批判性思维能力是决策以及提供安全和优质患者护理的核心。在临床环境中监督和促进学生学习的人员需要培养学生的批判性思维能力。多年来,用于促进临床环境中学生学习的模式已经发生了变化,临床医生对患者护理和促进学生学习负有双重责任。许多护士没有接受过教育角色方面的培训。本研究改编了一项十五年前进行的比较研究。
描述性在线调查,包括三个涉及本科护理学生的急性护理患者场景。参与者被要求确定他们会就该场景向学生提出的问题。
来自一所澳大利亚大学的五个大型合作医疗保健组织的总共133名临床指导教师参与了研究,包括临床教师、临床教育工作者和带教老师。
所提出的问题大多是知识问题,这是认知领域中最低的类别,只需要简单回忆信息。参加过与教育相关的课程/研讨会或获得过正式资格的指导教师从更高认知水平提出的问题明显更多。
该研究提供了一些证据,表明临床环境中的护理指导教师主要向学生提出低层次问题。需要进一步研究以确定能够培养指导教师提出更高层次认知问题能力的策略。
临床指导教师应接受有针对性的教育,重点是如何为学生构建需要应用、分析、综合和评估的问题。