Patil Prateek C, Rathod Ashok K, Borde Mandar, Singh Vishwajeet, Singh Hemant U
Senior Registrar, Department of Orthopaedics, LTMMC and GH , Mumbai, Maharashtra, India .
Professor, Department of Orthopedics, LTMMC and GH , Mumbai, Maharashtra, India .
J Clin Diagn Res. 2016 Dec;10(12):RC05-RC08. doi: 10.7860/JCDR/2016/23376.8973. Epub 2016 Dec 1.
Traditionally, surgical intervention for patients with a spinal deformity has been considered for cosmetic benefits, but surgical intervention can alter the lung physiology or volumes and in turn leads to increase in physical capacity and exercise tolerance. Therefore, we conducted this to determine whether a surgical correction would restore the lung physiology, physical capacity and exercise tolerance in patients with kyphoscoliosis.
To evaluate the usage of six-minute walk test scores and modified Borg scores as tools/measures for exercise tolerance in patients with spinal deformity and to study the effects of surgical correction of spinal deformity on exercise tolerance with above parameters as the measures.
Thirty patients with spinal deformity, who had undergone surgery for deformity correction, were evaluated. All patients were investigated pre-operatively with x-rays of the spine (anteroposterior and lateral views). Clinical tests like breath holding time (after full inspiration) in number of seconds, modified Borg scores, six-minute walk test scores (heart rate, respiratory rate, maximum distance walked); were recorded as measures of exercise tolerance. The patients were followed up on the first, third, sixth and twelfth month post-operatively and tested clinically for breath holding time, modified Borg scores, six-minute walk test scores (heart rate, respiratory rate, maximum distance walked) and x-rays of the spine (anteroposterior and lateral views).
In our study, breath holding time (p-value = 0.001) and modified Borg scores (p-value = 0.012) showed a significant improvement at 12 months post-operatively. We noted similar findings with heart rate, respiratory rate and maximum distance walked after a six-minute walk test. Improvements were noted in all the parameters, especially in the group of patients with greater than 60 degrees of cobb angle. However, the differences between the two groups (pre-operative cobb angle less than 60 degrees and pre-operative cobb angle more than 60 degrees) were not significant. The results were analysed and tested for significance using Student's t-test (paired and unpaired as appropriate) and Wilcoxon signed rank test.
Surgical correction in cases of spinal deformity improves the cosmetic appearance and balance in the patients. Favourable results of surgical intervention were found in exercise tolerance with improvements in modified Borg scores, six-minute walk test results and breath holding time. The above parameters appear to be good tools for the assessment of physical capacity and exercise tolerance in patients with spinal deformity.
传统上,脊柱畸形患者接受手术干预主要是为了美观,但手术干预会改变肺部生理功能或容积,进而提高身体能力和运动耐量。因此,我们开展此项研究以确定手术矫正是否能恢复脊柱侧凸患者的肺部生理功能、身体能力和运动耐量。
评估六分钟步行试验评分和改良Borg评分作为脊柱畸形患者运动耐量的工具/指标的应用情况,并以上述参数为指标研究脊柱畸形手术矫正对运动耐量的影响。
对30例接受畸形矫正手术的脊柱畸形患者进行评估。所有患者术前均行脊柱X线检查(正位和侧位片)。记录屏气时间(深吸气后)(以秒计)、改良Borg评分、六分钟步行试验评分(心率、呼吸频率、行走最大距离)等临床测试结果作为运动耐量指标。术后第1、3、6和12个月对患者进行随访,并进行屏气时间、改良Borg评分、六分钟步行试验评分(心率、呼吸频率、行走最大距离)的临床测试以及脊柱X线检查(正位和侧位片)。
在我们的研究中,术后12个月屏气时间(p值 = 0.001)和改良Borg评分(p值 = 0.012)有显著改善。六分钟步行试验后,心率、呼吸频率和行走最大距离也有类似结果。所有参数均有改善,尤其是Cobb角大于60度的患者组。然而,两组(术前Cobb角小于60度和术前Cobb角大于60度)之间的差异不显著。采用Student's t检验(根据情况进行配对和非配对)和Wilcoxon符号秩检验对结果进行分析和显著性检验。
脊柱畸形手术矫正可改善患者的外观和平衡。手术干预在运动耐量方面取得了良好效果,改良Borg评分、六分钟步行试验结果和屏气时间均有改善。上述参数似乎是评估脊柱畸形患者身体能力和运动耐量的良好工具。