Lopez Priscilla M, Islam Nadia, Feinberg Alexis, Myers Christa, Seidl Lois, Drackett Elizabeth, Riley Lindsey, Mata Andrea, Pinzon Juan, Benjamin Elisabeth, Wyka Katarzyna, Dannefer Rachel, Lopez Javier, Trinh-Shevrin Chau, Aletha Maybank Karen, Thorpe Lorna E
New York University School of Medicine, NYU-CUNY Prevention Research Center, New York, New York.
New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, Long Island City, New York.
Am J Prev Med. 2017 Mar;52(3 Suppl 3):S284-S289. doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2016.08.034.
This study examined feasibility of a place-based community health worker (CHW) and health advocate (HA) initiative in five public housing developments selected for high chronic disease burden and described early outcomes.
This intervention was informed by a mixed-method needs assessment performed December 2014-January 2015 (representative telephone survey, n=1,663; six focus groups, n=55). Evaluation design was a non-randomized, controlled quasi-experiment. Intake and 3-month follow-up data were collected February-December 2015 (follow-up response rate, 93%) on 224 intervention and 176 comparison participants, and analyzed in 2016. All participants self-reported diagnoses of hypertension, diabetes, or asthma. The intervention consisted of chronic disease self-management and goal setting through six individual CHW-led health coaching sessions, instrumental support, and facilitated access to insurance/clinical care navigation from community-based HAs. Feasibility measures included CHW service satisfaction and successful goal setting. Preliminary outcomes included clinical measures (blood pressure, BMI); disease management behaviors and self-efficacy; and preventive behaviors (physical activity).
At the 3-month follow-up, nearly all intervention participants reported high satisfaction with their CHW (90%) and HA (76%). Intervention participants showed significant improvements in self-reported physical activity (p=0.005) and, among hypertensive participants, self-reported routine blood pressure self-monitoring (p=0.013) compared with comparison participants. No improvements were observed in self-efficacy or clinical measures at the 3-month follow-up.
Housing-based initiatives involving CHW and HA teams are acceptable to public housing residents and can be effectively implemented to achieve rapid improvements in physical activity and chronic disease self-management. At 3-month assessment, additional time and efforts are required to improve clinical outcomes.
本研究考察了在五个因慢性病负担重而被选中的公共住房开发区开展以社区为基础的社区卫生工作者(CHW)和健康倡导者(HA)倡议的可行性,并描述了早期成果。
该干预措施基于2014年12月至2015年1月进行的一项混合方法需求评估(代表性电话调查,n = 1663;六个焦点小组,n = 55)。评估设计为非随机对照准实验。2015年2月至12月收集了224名干预参与者和176名对照参与者的入组数据和3个月随访数据(随访应答率为93%),并于2016年进行分析。所有参与者均自我报告患有高血压、糖尿病或哮喘。干预措施包括通过六次由社区卫生工作者主导的个人健康指导课程进行慢性病自我管理和目标设定、提供工具性支持以及由社区健康倡导者协助获得保险/临床护理指导。可行性指标包括社区卫生工作者服务满意度和成功的目标设定。初步成果包括临床指标(血压、体重指数);疾病管理行为和自我效能;以及预防行为(身体活动)。
在3个月随访时,几乎所有干预参与者都对他们的社区卫生工作者(90%)和健康倡导者(76%)表示高度满意。与对照参与者相比,干预参与者自我报告的身体活动有显著改善(p = 0.005),在高血压参与者中,自我报告的常规血压自我监测也有显著改善(p = 0.013)。在3个月随访时,自我效能或临床指标未观察到改善。
涉及社区卫生工作者和健康倡导者团队的基于住房的倡议为公共住房居民所接受,并且可以有效实施以快速改善身体活动和慢性病自我管理。在3个月评估时,需要额外的时间和努力来改善临床结果。