Livshits Gregory, Malkin Ida, Freidin Maxim B, Xia Yudong, Gao Fei, Wang Jun, Spector Timothy D, MacGregor Alex, Bell Jordana T, Williams Frances M K
aDepartment of Twin Research and Genetic Epidemiology, King's College London, London, United Kingdom bDepartment of Anatomy and Anthropology, Sackler Faculty of Medicine, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel cBeiging Genomic Institute-Shenzhen, Shenzhen, China dSchool of Medicine, University of East Anglia, Norwich, United Kingdom.
Pain. 2017 Jun;158(6):1053-1062. doi: 10.1097/j.pain.0000000000000880.
Chronic widespread musculoskeletal pain (CWP), has a considerable heritable component, which remains to be explained. Epigenetic factors may contribute to and account for some of the heritability estimate. We analysed epigenome-wide methylation using MeDIPseq in whole blood DNA from 1708 monozygotic and dizygotic Caucasian twins having CWP prevalence of 19.9%. Longitudinally stable methylation bins (lsBINs), were established by testing repeated measurements conducted ≥3 years apart, n = 292. DNA methylation variation at lsBINs was tested for association with CWP in a discovery set of 50 monozygotic twin pairs discordant for CWP, and in an independent dataset (n = 1608 twins), and the results from the 2 samples were combined using Fisher method. Functional interpretation of the most associated signals was based on functional genomic annotations, gene ontology, and pathway analyses. Of 723,029 signals identified as lsBINs, 26,399 lsBINs demonstrated the same direction of association in both discovery and replication datasets at nominal significance (P ≤ 0.05). In the combined analysis across 1708 individuals, whereas no lsBINs showed genome-wide significance (P < 10-8), 24 signals reached p≤9E-5, and these included association signals mapping in or near to IL17A, ADIPOR2, and TNFRSF13B. Bioinformatics analyses of the associated methylation bins showed enrichment for neurological pathways in CWP. We estimate that the variance explained by epigenetic factors in CWP is 6%. This, the largest study to date of DNA methylation in CWP, points towards epigenetic modification of neurological pathways in CWP and provides proof of principle of this method in teasing apart the complex risk factors for CWP.
慢性广泛性肌肉骨骼疼痛(CWP)具有相当大的遗传成分,这一点尚待解释。表观遗传因素可能有助于解释部分遗传度估计值。我们使用MeDIPseq技术对1708对高加索单卵和双卵双胞胎全血DNA中的表观基因组甲基化进行了分析,这些双胞胎中CWP患病率为19.9%。通过测试间隔≥3年进行的重复测量,建立了纵向稳定的甲基化区间(lsBINs),n = 292。在一组50对CWP不一致的单卵双胞胎发现集以及一个独立数据集(n = 1608对双胞胎)中,测试了lsBINs处的DNA甲基化变异与CWP的关联,并使用Fisher方法合并了两个样本的结果。对最相关信号的功能解释基于功能基因组注释、基因本体和通路分析。在被鉴定为lsBINs的723,029个信号中,26,399个lsBINs在发现集和复制数据集中均显示出相同方向的关联,具有名义显著性(P≤0.05)。在对1708名个体的联合分析中,虽然没有lsBINs显示出全基因组显著性(P < 10-8),但有24个信号达到p≤9E-5,其中包括映射在IL17A、ADIPOR2和TNFRSF13B内或附近的关联信号。对相关甲基化区间的生物信息学分析显示,CWP中神经通路富集。我们估计表观遗传因素在CWP中解释的方差为6%。这是迄今为止关于CWP中DNA甲基化的最大规模研究,表明CWP中神经通路存在表观遗传修饰,并为该方法在梳理CWP复杂风险因素方面提供了原理证明。