Lux Cassie N, Culp William T N, Johnson Lynelle R, Kent Michael, Mayhew Philipp, Daniaux Lise A, Carr Alaina, Puchalski Sarah
Department of Surgical and Radiological Sciences, School of Veterinary Medicine, University of California-Davis, Davis, CA, 95616.
Department of Small Animal Clinical Sciences, College of Veterinary Medicine, University of Tennessee, 2407 River Dr, Knoxville, TN, 37996.
Vet Radiol Ultrasound. 2017 May;58(3):315-325. doi: 10.1111/vru.12486. Epub 2017 Feb 24.
Identification of nasal neoplasia extension and tumor staging in dogs is most commonly performed using computed tomography (CT), however magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is routinely used in human medicine. A prospective pilot study enrolling six dogs with nasal neoplasia was performed with CT and MRI studies acquired under the same anesthetic episode. Interobserver comparison and comparison between the two imaging modalities with regard to bidimensional measurements of the nasal tumors, tumor staging using historical schemes, and assignment of an ordinal scale of tumor margin clarity at the tumor-soft tissue interface were performed. The hypotheses included that MRI would have greater tumor measurements, result in higher tumor staging, and more clearly define the tumor soft tissue interface when compared to CT. Evaluation of bone involvement of the nasal cavity and head showed a high level of agreement between CT and MRI. Estimation of tumor volume using bidimensional measurements was higher on MRI imaging in 5/6 dogs, and resulted in a median tumor volume which was 18.4% higher than CT imaging. Disagreement between CT and MRI was noted with meningeal enhancement, in which two dogs were positive for meningeal enhancement on MRI and negative on CT. One of six dogs had a higher tumor stage on MRI compared to CT, while the remaining five agreed. Magnetic resonance imaging resulted in larger bidimensional measurements and tumor volume estimates, along with a higher likelihood of identifying meningeal enhancement when compared to CT imaging. Magnetic resonance imaging may provide integral information for tumor staging, prognosis, and treatment planning.
犬鼻腔肿瘤扩展的识别和肿瘤分期最常用计算机断层扫描(CT)来进行,然而磁共振成像(MRI)在人类医学中是常规使用的。一项前瞻性试点研究纳入了6只患有鼻腔肿瘤的犬,在同一麻醉期内进行了CT和MRI检查。对鼻腔肿瘤的二维测量、使用历史方案进行肿瘤分期以及在肿瘤-软组织界面处确定肿瘤边缘清晰度的序数尺度方面,进行了观察者间比较以及两种成像方式之间的比较。假设包括与CT相比,MRI将有更大的肿瘤测量值、导致更高的肿瘤分期并且更清晰地界定肿瘤软组织界面。对鼻腔和头部的骨受累情况评估显示,CT和MRI之间有高度一致性。在6只犬中的5只中,使用二维测量估计的肿瘤体积在MRI成像上更高,并且导致的中位肿瘤体积比CT成像高18.4%。在脑膜强化方面注意到CT和MRI之间存在分歧,其中2只犬在MRI上脑膜强化呈阳性而在CT上呈阴性。6只犬中有1只的MRI肿瘤分期高于CT,而其余5只一致。与CT成像相比,磁共振成像导致更大的二维测量值和肿瘤体积估计值,以及更高的识别脑膜强化的可能性。磁共振成像可为肿瘤分期、预后和治疗规划提供不可或缺的信息。