van Asseldonk M, van Wagenberg C P A, Wisselink H J
Wageningen Economic Research, Wageningen UR, The Netherlands.
Wageningen Economic Research, Wageningen UR, The Netherlands.
Prev Vet Med. 2017 Mar 1;138:139-146. doi: 10.1016/j.prevetmed.2017.01.016. Epub 2017 Jan 29.
Toxoplasma gondii (T. gondii) is a food safety hazard which causes a substantial human disease burden and cost-of-illness. Infected pig meat is a common source of toxoplasmosis. A break-even analysis was conducted to estimate the point for which the intervention cost at fattening pig farms equaled the cost of averted human disease burden and cost-of-illness minus the costs of a T. gondii surveillance program. The surveillance program comprised serological testing of blood samples taken at slaughter. Break-even points were determined given alternative levels of the effectiveness of the intervention program (10% up to 90% in steps of 10%), the value of an averted DALY (20,000, 50,000 and 80,000 Euro), and threshold of sample prevalence for a farm to be under intervention (5% up to 50% out of 20 samples in steps of 5%). Since test characteristics are a determining factor in the break-even analysis, and literature is inconclusive concerning sensitivity (se) and specificity (sp) of the serological test kit used, two alternative sets of assumptions were analysed. The estimated maximum costs of an intervention if only benefits for domestic consumers were accounted amounted approximately 2981 Euro (se=98.9% and sp=92.7%) versus 4389 Euro (se=65.2% and sp=97.4%) per year per fattening pig farm under intervention assuming an effectiveness of 50%, 50,000 Euro per averted DALY and threshold T. gondii sample prevalence of 5% for a farm to be under intervention. Since almost 80% of the gross domestic production is exported corresponding break-even values increased up to 12,034 Euro and 18,366 Euro if benefits for consumers abroad were included as well. Empirical research to strengthen the knowledge about the efficacy of a farm intervention measures is recommended.
刚地弓形虫是一种食品安全危害因素,会给人类带来巨大的疾病负担和疾病成本。受感染的猪肉是弓形虫病的常见传染源。进行了一项盈亏平衡分析,以估算育肥猪场的干预成本等于避免的人类疾病负担和疾病成本减去弓形虫监测计划成本的那个点。该监测计划包括对屠宰时采集的血样进行血清学检测。根据干预计划的不同有效性水平(从10%到90%,步长为10%)、避免的伤残调整生命年(DALY)的价值(20,000欧元、50,000欧元和80,000欧元)以及农场接受干预的样本流行率阈值(20个样本中从5%到50%,步长为5%)来确定盈亏平衡点。由于检测特征是盈亏平衡分析的一个决定因素,且关于所用血清学检测试剂盒的灵敏度(se)和特异性(sp)的文献尚无定论,因此分析了两组替代假设。如果仅考虑国内消费者的受益情况,在假设干预有效性为50%、每个避免的DALY价值为50,000欧元且农场接受干预的弓形虫样本流行率阈值为5%的情况下,每个受干预的育肥猪场每年的干预估计最大成本约为2981欧元(se = 98.9%且sp = 92.7%),而另一种情况为4389欧元(se = 65.2%且sp = 97.4%)。由于国内生产总值近80%用于出口,如果也将国外消费者的受益情况包括在内,相应的盈亏平衡值将增至12,034欧元和18,366欧元。建议开展实证研究以加强对农场干预措施效果的了解。