Zhou James Jun, Koltz Michael T, Agarwal Nitin, Tempel Zachary J, Kanter Adam S, Okonkwo David O, Hamilton D Kojo
Department of Neurological Surgery, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine and Medical Center, Pittsburgh, PA.
Dell Medical School, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX.
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2017 Mar;42(5):336-344. doi: 10.1097/BRS.0000000000001860.
Bibliometric analysis.
To apply the established technique of citation analysis to identify the 100 most influential articles in scoliosis surgery research published between 1900 and 2015.
Previous studies have applied the technique of citation analysis to other areas of study. This is the first article to apply this technique to the field of scoliosis surgery.
A two-step search of the Thomson Reuters Web of Science was conducted to identify all articles relevant to the field of scoliosis surgery. The top 100 articles with the most citations were identified based on analysis of titles and abstracts. Further statistical analysis was conducted to determine whether measures of author reputation and overall publication influence affected the rate at which publications were recognized and incorporated by other researchers in the field.
Total citations for the final 100 publications included in the list ranged from 82 to 509. The period for publication ranged from 1954 to 2010. Most studies were published in the journal Spine (n = 63). The most frequently published topics of study were surgical techniques (n = 35) and outcomes (n = 35). Measures of author reputation (number of total studies in the top 100, number of first-author studies in the top 100) were found to have no effect on the rate at which studies were adopted by other researchers (number of years until first citation, and number of years until maximum citations). The number of citations/year a publication received was found to be negatively correlated with the rate at which it was adopted by other researchers, indicating that more influential manuscripts attained more rapid recognition by the scientific community at large.
In assembling this publication, we have strived to identify and recognize the 100 most influential articles in scoliosis surgery research from 1900 to 2015.
N/A.
文献计量分析。
应用已确立的引文分析技术,识别1900年至2015年间发表的脊柱侧弯手术研究中最具影响力的100篇文章。
以往研究已将引文分析技术应用于其他研究领域。本文是将该技术应用于脊柱侧弯手术领域的首篇文章。
对汤森路透科学网进行两步检索,以识别与脊柱侧弯手术领域相关的所有文章。通过对标题和摘要的分析,确定被引次数最多的前100篇文章。进一步进行统计分析,以确定作者声誉指标和总体发表影响力是否会影响该领域其他研究人员认可和引用这些出版物的速度。
列入清单的最终100篇出版物的总被引次数在82至509次之间。发表时间跨度为1954年至2010年。大多数研究发表于《脊柱》杂志(n = 63)。最常发表的研究主题是手术技术(n = 35)和结果(n = 35)。发现作者声誉指标(前100篇中的研究总数、前100篇中的第一作者研究数)对其他研究人员采用这些研究的速度(首次被引用的年份数、达到最高被引次数的年份数)没有影响。发现一篇出版物每年获得的被引次数与其他研究人员采用它的速度呈负相关,这表明更具影响力的手稿能更快地得到整个科学界的认可。
在汇编本出版物时,我们努力识别并认可1900年至2015年间脊柱侧弯手术研究中最具影响力的100篇文章。
无。