缓慢刷牙可减轻人类的热痛。
Slow brushing reduces heat pain in humans.
作者信息
Liljencrantz J, Strigo I, Ellingsen D M, Krämer H H, Lundblad L C, Nagi S S, Leknes S, Olausson H
机构信息
Institute of Neuroscience and Physiology, University of Gothenburg, Sweden.
VA San Francisco Healthcare System, USA.
出版信息
Eur J Pain. 2017 Aug;21(7):1173-1185. doi: 10.1002/ejp.1018. Epub 2017 Mar 6.
BACKGROUND
C-tactile (CT) afferents are unmyelinated low-threshold mechanoreceptors optimized for signalling affective, gentle touch. In three separate psychophysical experiments, we examined the contribution of CT afferents to pain modulation.
METHODS
In total, 44 healthy volunteers experienced heat pain and CT optimal (slow brushing) and CT sub-optimal (fast brushing or vibration) stimuli. Three different experimental paradigms were used: Concurrent application of heat pain and tactile (slow brushing or vibration) stimulation; Slow brushing, applied for variable duration and intervals, preceding heat pain; Slow versus fast brushing preceding heat pain.
RESULTS
Slow brushing was effective in reducing pain, whereas fast brushing or vibration was not. The reduction in pain was significant not only when the CT optimal touch was applied simultaneously with the painful stimulus but also when the two stimuli were separated in time. For subsequent stimulation, the pain reduction was more pronounced for a shorter time interval between brushing and pain. Likewise, the effect was more robust when pain was preceded by a longer duration of brush stimulation. Strong CT-related pain reduction was associated with low anxiety and high calmness scores obtained by a state anxiety questionnaire.
CONCLUSIONS
Slow brushing - optimal for CT activation - is effective in reducing pain from cutaneous heating. The precise mechanisms for the pain relief are as yet unknown but possible mechanisms include inhibition of nociceptive projection neurons at the level of the dorsal horn as well as analgesia through cortical mechanisms.
SIGNIFICANCE
Slow brushing stimuli - optimal for activation of C-tactile fibres - can reduce pain from cutaneous heating. No such effect was seen with fast brushing or vibration. These observations indicate the role of C-tactile fibres in pain modulation.
背景
C类触觉(CT)传入神经是无髓鞘的低阈值机械感受器,专为传递情感性的轻柔触觉信号而优化。在三项独立的心理物理学实验中,我们研究了CT传入神经对疼痛调节的作用。
方法
共有44名健康志愿者经历了热痛以及CT最佳(慢刷)和CT次佳(快刷或振动)刺激。使用了三种不同的实验范式:热痛与触觉(慢刷或振动)刺激同时应用;在热痛之前以可变的持续时间和间隔应用慢刷;热痛之前慢刷与快刷对比。
结果
慢刷能有效减轻疼痛,而快刷或振动则不能。不仅在CT最佳触觉与疼痛刺激同时应用时疼痛减轻显著,而且当两种刺激在时间上分开时也是如此。对于后续刺激,刷动与疼痛之间的时间间隔越短,疼痛减轻越明显。同样,当疼痛之前有更长持续时间的刷动刺激时,效果更强。与CT相关的强烈疼痛减轻与状态焦虑问卷获得的低焦虑和高平静分数相关。
结论
慢刷——对CT激活最佳——能有效减轻皮肤加热引起的疼痛。疼痛缓解的确切机制尚不清楚,但可能的机制包括在背角水平抑制伤害性投射神经元以及通过皮质机制产生镇痛作用。
意义
慢刷刺激——对C类触觉纤维激活最佳——可减轻皮肤加热引起的疼痛。快刷或振动则未见此效果。这些观察结果表明C类触觉纤维在疼痛调节中的作用。