Shingler Ellie, Hackshaw-McGeagh Lucy, Robles Luke, Persad Raj, Koupparis Anthony, Rowe Edward, Shiridzinomwa Constance, Bahl Amit, Martin Richard M, Lane J Athene
University of Bristol, Bristol, UK.
Bristol Urological Institute, Bristol, UK.
Trials. 2017 Mar 7;18(1):106. doi: 10.1186/s13063-017-1828-4.
There is increasing evidence that low levels of physical activity and diets low in fruit and vegetables and high in meat and dairy products are risk factors for prostate cancer disease progression. The Prostate cancer: Evidence of Exercise and Nutrition Trial (PrEvENT) aimed to assess a diet and physical activity intervention in men undergoing radical prostatectomy for localized prostate cancer. The trial included a qualitative component to explore the experiences of men participating in the trial in order to understand the acceptability of the intervention and data collection methods. We report the qualitative findings of the trial and consider how these can be used to inform future research.
PrEvENT involved randomizing men to either a dietary and/or physical activity intervention. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with a purposive sample of 17 men on completion of the 6 month trial. Interviews took place in clinic or as telephone interviews, if requested by the participant, and were audio recorded, transcribed, and analyzed using the thematic-based framework approach. Analysis was conducted throughout the data collection process to allow emergent themes to be further explored in subsequent interviews.
Three overarching themes were identified: acceptability of the intervention, acceptability of the data collection methods and trial logistics. Participants were predominantly positive about both the dietary and physical activity interventions and most men found the methods of data collection appropriate. Recommendations for future trials include consideration of alternative physical activity options, such as cycling or gym sessions, increased information on portion sizes, the potential importance of including wives or partners in the dietary change process and the possibility of using the pedometer or other wearable technology as part of the physical activity intervention.
We provide insight into the opinions and experiences of the acceptability of the PrEvENT diet and physical activity intervention from the participants themselves. The interventions delivered were acceptable to this sample of participants, as were the data collection methods utilized. We also highlight some considerations for further behavioural change interventions in prostate cancer and other similar populations.
ISRCTN, ISRCTN99048944 . Registered on 17 November 2014.
越来越多的证据表明,低水平的体育活动以及水果和蔬菜摄入量低、肉类和奶制品摄入量高的饮食是前列腺癌疾病进展的危险因素。前列腺癌:运动与营养试验证据(PrEvENT)旨在评估对接受局限性前列腺癌根治术的男性进行饮食和体育活动干预的效果。该试验包括一个定性部分,以探索参与试验的男性的经历,从而了解干预措施和数据收集方法的可接受性。我们报告该试验的定性结果,并考虑如何将这些结果用于为未来的研究提供信息。
PrEvENT试验将男性随机分为饮食和/或体育活动干预组。在为期6个月的试验结束时,对17名男性进行了有目的抽样的半结构化访谈。访谈在诊所进行,或者如果参与者要求,也可以通过电话访谈进行,并进行录音、转录,然后使用基于主题的框架方法进行分析。在整个数据收集过程中进行分析,以便在后续访谈中进一步探讨新出现的主题。
确定了三个总体主题:干预措施的可接受性、数据收集方法的可接受性和试验后勤。参与者对饮食和体育活动干预大多持积极态度,大多数男性认为数据收集方法合适。对未来试验的建议包括考虑其他体育活动选项,如骑自行车或参加健身课程,增加关于食物份量的信息,在饮食改变过程中纳入妻子或伴侣的潜在重要性,以及将计步器或其他可穿戴技术用作体育活动干预一部分的可能性。
我们深入了解了参与者对PrEvENT饮食和体育活动干预可接受性的意见和经历。所提供的干预措施对该样本的参与者来说是可以接受的,所使用的数据收集方法也是如此。我们还强调了在前列腺癌和其他类似人群中进一步进行行为改变干预的一些注意事项。
ISRCTN,ISRCTN99048944。于2014年11月17日注册。