Baker Timothy, Kumar Koshila, Kennedy Marcus
Centre for Rural Emergency Medicine, Deakin University School of Medicine, Geelong, Victoria, Australia.
Flinders Rural Health South Australia, Flinders University, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia.
Emerg Med Australas. 2017 Jun;29(3):342-347. doi: 10.1111/1742-6723.12754. Epub 2017 Mar 8.
This study explores how rural junior doctors learn while consulting retrieval physicians about critically ill and injured patients, as well as the tensions characterising teaching and learning in this setting.
Data were collected via three focus groups, involving rural junior doctors (n = 8), rural senior doctors (n = 3) and retrievalists (n = 3). The discussions were transcribed and subject to multistage coding.
Rural junior doctors believe they learn from interactions with retrieval physicians. Their learning was greatest when the retrieval physician explained his or her clinical reasoning and provided feedback. The level of stress was sometimes overwhelming and learning ceased. Both groups described limited time for teaching due to the medical needs of the patient and the needs of concurrent patients. Retrieval physicians were not certain that rural junior doctors wanted to learn. Rural junior doctors hold retrievalists in very high regard.
Support provided by retrievalists extends the abilities of the junior doctors and often results in learning. When junior doctors are extended too far, they become overwhelmed and learning ceases. Junior doctors would like the retrievalists to spend more time explaining their actions and providing feedback. Even when both retrievalists and junior doctors are interested in teaching, it may not occur due to misunderstandings and differences in status.
本研究探讨农村初级医生在就危重伤病患者咨询急救医生时是如何学习的,以及这种情况下教学与学习的紧张关系。
通过三个焦点小组收集数据,参与人员包括农村初级医生(n = 8)、农村高级医生(n = 3)和急救医生(n = 3)。讨论内容被转录并进行多阶段编码。
农村初级医生认为他们从与急救医生的互动中学习。当急救医生解释其临床推理并提供反馈时,他们学到的最多。压力程度有时令人难以承受,学习就会停止。两组都表示由于患者的医疗需求和同时期其他患者的需求,教学时间有限。急救医生不确定农村初级医生是否想学。农村初级医生对急救医生评价很高。
急救医生提供的支持扩展了初级医生的能力,且常常带来学习效果。当对初级医生要求过高时,他们会不堪重负,学习就会停止。初级医生希望急救医生花更多时间解释其行为并提供反馈。即使急救医生和初级医生都对教学感兴趣,由于误解和地位差异,教学也可能无法进行。