Raymond M R
Center for Credentialing Services, American Nurses' Association, Kansas City, Missouri.
J Nurs Educ. 1988 Jan;27(1):6-9. doi: 10.3928/0148-4834-19880101-04.
The purpose of this study was to investigate the empirical relationship between level of educational preparation and performance on certification examinations. Data from 12 different examinations administered by ANA in 1985 were available for a total sample of 12,308 RNs. Standardized effect sizes were computed for the following comparisons: baccalaureate vs. prebaccalaureate (associate degree and diploma), master's vs. baccalaureate, and master's vs. prebaccalaureate. Results were cumulated, averaged, and compared using meta-analytic procedures. The major finding was that effect sizes were consistently positive and statistically significant, indicating that nurses with more education generally obtain higher scores than those with less education. The present findings are discussed in the context of the widely known finding that baccalaureate candidates for RN licensure generally score lower than associate degree and diploma-prepared candidates on the RN licensure examination. It is suggested that the disparity in findings is not necessarily anomalous, given that licensure and certification serve very different functions.
本研究的目的是调查教育准备水平与资格考试成绩之间的实证关系。美国护士协会(ANA)在1985年进行的12项不同考试的数据可供12308名注册护士的总样本使用。针对以下比较计算标准化效应量:学士学位与学士学位以下(副学士学位和文凭)、硕士学位与学士学位、硕士学位与学士学位以下。使用元分析程序对结果进行累积、平均和比较。主要发现是效应量始终为正且具有统计学意义,表明受教育程度较高的护士通常比受教育程度较低的护士获得更高的分数。本文的研究结果是在一个广为人知的发现背景下进行讨论的,即获得学士学位的注册护士执照候选人在注册护士执照考试中的得分通常低于副学士学位和文凭学历的候选人。有人认为,鉴于执照和认证的功能截然不同,研究结果的差异不一定异常。