Ahalt Cyrus, Haney Craig, Rios Sarah, Fox Matthew P, Farabee David, Williams Brie
University of California, San Francisco , San Francisco, California, USA.
University of California, Santa Cruz , Santa Cruz, California, USA.
Int J Prison Health. 2017 Mar 13;13(1):41-48. doi: 10.1108/IJPH-08-2016-0040.
Purpose Although the reform of solitary confinement is underway in many jurisdictions around world, isolation remains in widespread use in many jails and prisons. The purpose of this paper is to discuss opportunities for reform in the USA that could also be applied globally. Design/methodology/approach A review of the evidence on solitary confinement policies and practices in the USA to develop recommendations for reform with global application. Findings Focusing on this evidence, the authors argue that solitary confinement is overused and recommend a multi-level approach available to correctional systems worldwide including: immediately limiting solitary confinement to only those cases in which a violent behavioral infraction has been committed for which safety cannot otherwise be achieved, ensuring the briefest terms of isolation needed to achieve legitimate and immediate correctional goals, prohibiting its use entirely for some populations, regularly reviewing all isolated prisoners for as-soon-as-possible return to general population, including the immediate return of those showing mental and physical health risk factors, assisting individuals who are transitioning out of isolation (either to the general population or to the community), and partnering with medical, public health, and criminal justice experts to develop evidence-based alternatives to solitary confinement for nearly all prisoners. Originality/value This paper provides an overview of the evidence supporting an overhaul of solitary confinement policy in the USA and globally where solitary confinement remains in wide use and offers recommendations for immediate steps that can be taken toward achieving evidence-based solitary confinement reform.
目的 尽管世界各地许多司法管辖区都在进行单独监禁改革,但隔离措施在许多监狱中仍被广泛使用。本文旨在探讨美国的改革机会,这些机会也可在全球范围内应用。 设计/方法/途径 回顾美国单独监禁政策和做法的证据,以制定具有全球适用性的改革建议。 研究结果 基于这些证据,作者认为单独监禁被过度使用,并建议全球惩教系统采用多层次方法,包括:立即将单独监禁限制在仅针对那些实施了暴力违规行为且无法通过其他方式确保安全的情况;确保为实现合理且紧迫的惩教目标所需的最短隔离期限;完全禁止对某些人群使用单独监禁;定期审查所有被隔离的囚犯,以便尽快让他们回到普通人群中,包括立即让那些存在身心健康风险因素的囚犯回归;协助那些从隔离状态过渡出来的人(无论是回到普通人群还是社区);与医学、公共卫生和刑事司法专家合作,为几乎所有囚犯制定基于证据的替代单独监禁的措施。 原创性/价值 本文概述了支持美国及全球范围内单独监禁政策全面改革的证据,在全球单独监禁仍被广泛使用的情况下,本文还就实现基于证据的单独监禁改革可立即采取的措施提出了建议。