Firbank L G, Watkinson A R
School of Biological Sciences, University of East Anglia, NR4 7TJ, Norwich, UK.
Oecologia. 1987 Jan;71(2):308-317. doi: 10.1007/BF00377300.
The extent to which some measure of local crowding can account for the performance of individual plants is examined with reference to populations of two species of annual plant. Only a relatively small proportion of the variation in individual plant yield could be accounted for by measures of local crowding. These included the number of close neighbours, an estimate of the area available to each plant and competitive pressure. A multiple regression that took account of both emergence time and local crowding increased the proportion of variance that could be accounted for up to 50%. Computer simulations of the growth of indivudual plants in monoculture were then caried out in order to determine whether the unexplained variation resulted from fundamental flaws in the models or from unaccounted for sources of variation in the field. The results from the simulations again indicated that only a relatively low proportion of the variation in individual plant yield could be accounted for by emergence time and local density, even though these were known to be the only variables present. These findings are discussed in relation to the relative importance of one-sided and two-sided competition, and the complex cross-correlations that occur between individuals in plant populations. These two factors will make it very difficult for field workers to determine accurately what factors determine individual plant yield and in particular to predict the effects of local crowding on the performance of individual plants.
参照两种一年生植物的种群,研究了局部拥挤的某种度量能够解释单株植物表现的程度。单株植物产量变化中只有相对较小的比例能够通过局部拥挤的度量来解释。这些度量包括相邻近植株的数量、对每株植物可利用面积的估计以及竞争压力。一个同时考虑出苗时间和局部拥挤的多元回归将能够解释的方差比例提高到了50%。随后对单一栽培中个体植物的生长进行了计算机模拟,以确定无法解释的变异是源于模型中的基本缺陷还是源于田间未考虑到的变异来源。模拟结果再次表明,即使已知出苗时间和局部密度是仅有的变量,单株植物产量变化中也只有相对较低的比例能够通过它们来解释。结合单边竞争和双边竞争的相对重要性以及植物种群中个体之间出现的复杂交叉相关性对这些发现进行了讨论。这两个因素将使得田间工作者很难准确确定哪些因素决定单株植物产量,尤其是预测局部拥挤对单株植物表现的影响。