Dunleavy Kim, Chevan Julia, Sander Antoinette P, Gasherebuka Jean Damascene, Mann Monika
a Department of Physical Therapy , University of Florida , Gainesville , FL , USA.
b Health Volunteers Overseas , Washington , DC , USA.
Disabil Rehabil. 2018 Jun;40(13):1600-1608. doi: 10.1080/09638288.2017.1300692. Epub 2017 Mar 22.
Continuing professional development is an important component of capacity building in low resource countries. The purpose of this case study is to describe the use of a contextual instructional framework to guide the processes and instructional design choices for a series of continuing professional development courses for physiotherapists in Rwanda.
Four phases of the project are described: (1) program proposal, needs assessment and planning, (2) organization of the program and instructional design, (3) instructional delivery and (4) evaluation. Contextual facilitating factors and needs informed choices in each phase.
The model resulted in delivery of continuing professional development to the majority of physiotherapists in Rwanda (n = 168, 0.48 rural/0.52 urban) with participants reporting improvement in skills and perceived benefit for their patients. Environmental and healthcare system factors resulted in offering the courses in rural and urban areas. Content was developed and delivered in partnership with Rwandan coinstructors. Based on the domestic needs identified in early courses, the program included advocacy and leadership activities, in addition to practical and clinical instruction.
The contextual factors (environment, healthcare service organization, need for rehabilitation and status and history of the physiotherapy profession) were essential for project and instructional choices. Facilitating factors included the established professional degree and association, continuing professional development requirements, a core group of active professionals and an existing foundation from other projects. The processes and contextual considerations may be useful in countries with established professional-level education but without established postentry-level training. Implications for Rehabilitation Organizations planning continuing professional development programs may benefit from considering the context surrounding training when planning, designing and developing instruction. The surrounding context including the environment, the organization of healthcare services, the population defined need for rehabilitation, and the domestic status and history of the physiotherapy profession, is important for physiotherapy projects in countries with lower resources. Facilitating factors in low resource countries such as an established professional degree and association, continuing professional development requirements, a core group of active professionals and an existing foundation from other projects impact the success of projects. Methods that may be useful for relevance, dissemination and consistency include involvement of in-country leaders and instructors and attendance in multiple courses with consistent themes. Rehabilitation professionals in low resource countries may benefit from continuing professional development courses that emphasize practical skills, and clinical reasoning, accompanied by clinical mentoring and directed coaching that encourages knowledge transfer to the clinical setting. Active learning approaches and multiple progressive courses provide opportunities to develop peer support through professional communities of practice.
持续专业发展是资源匮乏国家能力建设的重要组成部分。本案例研究的目的是描述如何使用一种情境教学框架来指导为卢旺达物理治疗师开设的一系列持续专业发展课程的流程和教学设计选择。
描述了该项目的四个阶段:(1)项目提案、需求评估和规划,(2)项目组织和教学设计,(3)教学实施,以及(4)评估。情境促进因素和需求为每个阶段的选择提供了依据。
该模式为卢旺达的大多数物理治疗师(n = 168,农村/城市比例为0.48/0.52)提供了持续专业发展培训,参与者报告称其技能有所提高,并认为对患者有益。环境和医疗保健系统因素导致在农村和城市地区都开设了课程。内容是与卢旺达联合讲师合作开发和讲授的。根据早期课程中确定的国内需求,该项目除了提供实践和临床指导外,还包括宣传和领导活动。
情境因素(环境、医疗服务组织、康复需求以及物理治疗专业的地位和历史)对项目和教学选择至关重要。促进因素包括已确立的专业学位和协会、持续专业发展要求、一群活跃的专业核心人员以及其他项目奠定的基础。这些流程和情境考量对于拥有专业水平教育但尚未确立入职后培训的国家可能有用。对康复组织的启示:规划持续专业发展项目时,在规划、设计和开发教学内容时考虑培训的周边环境可能会有所裨益。周边环境,包括环境、医疗服务组织、人群对康复的明确需求以及物理治疗专业的国内地位和历史,对于资源较少国家的物理治疗项目很重要。资源匮乏国家的促进因素,如已确立的专业学位和协会、持续专业发展要求、一群活跃的专业核心人员以及其他项目奠定的基础,会影响项目的成功。对于相关性、传播和一致性可能有用的方法包括让国内领导人和讲师参与,以及参加主题一致的多门课程。资源匮乏国家的康复专业人员可能会从强调实践技能、临床推理,并伴有临床指导和定向辅导以鼓励知识转移到临床环境的持续专业发展课程中受益。积极的学习方法和多门进阶课程提供了通过专业实践社区发展同伴支持的机会。