Institute of Soil and Water Conservation, Northwest A&F University, Yangling 712100, China; Institute of Water Saving Agriculture in Arid Regions of China, Northwest A&F University, Yangling 712100, China.
Department of Renewable Resources, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2E3, Canada.
Sci Total Environ. 2017 Sep 1;593-594:54-64. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2017.03.158. Epub 2017 Mar 22.
Vegetative filter strips (VFSs) are a labor-saving and cost-effective agricultural best management practice to trap water runoff and sediment from the source areas. They also provide forage and/or fuel and are therefore potentially profitable for land owners. VFSs are however a dynamic system: the runoff delivery ratio (RDR) and sediment delivery ratio (SDR) vary with growth stage and vegetation types. The impacts of vegetation characteristics as well as soil physical properties modified by vegetation growth, on the RDR and SDR of VFS were evaluated by a flume experiment. Two plant species (cocksfoot (Dactylis glomerata L.) and white clover (Trifolium repens L.)) were tested at three stages in the growing season of 2016 (May, July, and August). The measured RDR and SDR were compared with the simulated results from Vegetative Filter Strip Modeling System (VFSMOD). In the early stages of the growing season, the cocksfoot formed a dense network of stems with high strip Manning's roughness faster than white clover. The runoff and sediment trapping effects of the white clover VFS were greater than that of cocksfoot VFS in all the three stages (lower RDR and SDR). This is likely attributed to strongly tillering, creeping stem posture and high infiltration capacity of the white clover VFS. VFSMOD simulated the RDR and SDR reliably except under low vegetation coverage conditions (white clover in May). The results suggested that (1) both soil physical properties and vegetation characteristics should be considered for the species-specific, temporally variable performance of VFS; and (2) when using VFSMOD inform the VFS design, modelers should take the dynamics of vegetation, mainly through vertical saturated hydraulic conductivity, stem spacing and strip Manning's roughness into account, and select parameters that reflect the actual field conditions.
植被过滤带(Vegetative Filter Strips, VFS)是一种节省劳动力和成本效益高的农业最佳管理实践,可以从源头捕获径流水和泥沙。它们还提供饲料和/或燃料,因此对土地所有者来说具有潜在的盈利性。然而,VFS 是一个动态系统:径流水输送比(Runoff Delivery Ratio, RDR)和泥沙输送比(Sediment Delivery Ratio, SDR)随生长阶段和植被类型而变化。通过水槽实验评估了植被特征以及植被生长改变的土壤物理特性对 VFS 的 RDR 和 SDR 的影响。在 2016 年生长季节的三个阶段(5 月、7 月和 8 月)测试了两种植物物种(鸭茅草(Dactylis glomerata L.)和白三叶草(Trifolium repens L.))。测量的 RDR 和 SDR 与 Vegetative Filter Strip Modeling System (VFSMOD)的模拟结果进行了比较。在生长季节的早期,鸭茅草比白三叶草更快地形成了一个密集的茎网,具有较高的带曼宁糙率。在所有三个阶段(较低的 RDR 和 SDR),白三叶草 VFS 的径流水和泥沙截留效果均大于鸭茅草 VFS。这可能归因于白三叶草 VFS 的分蘖能力强、匍匐茎姿态和高入渗能力。VFSMOD 可靠地模拟了 RDR 和 SDR,除了在低植被覆盖条件下(5 月的白三叶草)。结果表明:(1)在考虑 VFS 的特定物种、时间变化性能时,应同时考虑土壤物理特性和植被特征;(2)在使用 VFSMOD 进行 VFS 设计时,建模者应考虑植被的动态,主要是通过垂直饱和导水率、茎间距和带曼宁糙率,选择反映实际现场条件的参数。