Pan Steven C, Rickard Timothy C
Department of Psychology, University of California, San Diego.
J Exp Psychol Appl. 2017 Sep;23(3):278-292. doi: 10.1037/xap0000124. Epub 2017 Mar 30.
In many pedagogical contexts, term-definition facts that link a concept term (e.g., "vision") with its corresponding definition (e.g., "the ability to see") are learned. Does retrieval practice involving retrieval of the term (given the definition) or the definition (given the term) enhance subsequent recall, relative to restudy of the entire fact? Moreover, does any benefit of retrieval practice for the term transfer to later recall of the definition, or vice versa? We addressed those questions in 4 experiments. In each, subjects first studied term-definition facts and then trained on two thirds of the facts using multiple-choice tests with feedback. Half of the test questions involved recalling terms; the other half involved recalling definitions. The remaining facts were either not trained (Experiment 1) or restudied (Experiments 2-4). A 48-hr delayed multiple-choice (Experiments 1-2) or short answer (Experiments 3a-4) final test assessed recall of all terms or all definitions. Replicating and extending prior research, retrieval practice yielded improved recall and positive transfer relative to no training. Relative to restudy, however, retrieval practice consistently enhanced subsequent term retrieval, enhanced subsequent definition retrieval only after repeated practice, and consistently yielded at best minimal positive transfer in either direction. Theoretical and practical implications are discussed. (PsycINFO Database Record
在许多教学情境中,人们学习将概念术语(如“视觉”)与其相应定义(如“看见的能力”)联系起来的术语-定义性事实。与对整个事实进行重新学习相比,涉及检索术语(给出定义)或定义(给出术语)的检索练习是否能增强后续回忆?此外,检索练习对术语的任何益处是否会转移到对定义的后续回忆上,反之亦然?我们通过4个实验解决了这些问题。在每个实验中,受试者首先学习术语-定义性事实,然后使用有反馈的多项选择题对三分之二的事实进行训练。一半的测试问题涉及回忆术语;另一半涉及回忆定义。其余的事实要么不进行训练(实验1),要么进行重新学习(实验2-4)。一项48小时延迟的多项选择题(实验1-2)或简答题(实验3a-4)最终测试评估了所有术语或所有定义的回忆情况。重复并扩展先前的研究,与不训练相比,检索练习提高了回忆并产生了正向迁移。然而,与重新学习相比,检索练习始终能增强后续的术语检索,仅在重复练习后能增强后续的定义检索,并且在两个方向上始终最多只产生最小的正向迁移。我们讨论了理论和实践意义。(PsycINFO数据库记录)