Shaver John H, Sibley Chris G, Osborne Danny, Bulbulia Joseph
Religion Programme, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand.
School of Psychology, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
PLoS One. 2017 Mar 31;12(3):e0174606. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0174606. eCollection 2017.
News coverage of Islamic extremism is reigniting debates about the media's role in promoting prejudice toward Muslims. Psychological theories of media-induced prejudice date to the 1950's, and find support from controlled experiments. However, national-scale studies of media effects on Muslim prejudice are lacking. Orthogonal research investigating media-induced prejudice toward immigrants has failed to establish any link. Moreover, it has been found that people interpret the news in ways that confirm pre-existing attitudes, suggesting that media induced Muslim prejudice in liberal democracies is unlikely. Here, we test the association between news exposure and anti-Muslim prejudice in a diverse national sample from one of the world's most tolerant societies, where media effects are least likely to hold (N = 16,584, New Zealand). In support of media-induced Islamophobia, results show that greater news exposure is associated with both increased anger and reduced warmth toward Muslims. Additionally, the relationship between media exposure and anti-Muslim prejudice does not reliably vary with political ideology, supporting claims that it is widespread representations of Muslims in the news, rather than partisan media biases, that drives anti-Muslim prejudice.
对伊斯兰极端主义的新闻报道正在重新引发关于媒体在助长对穆斯林偏见方面所扮演角色的辩论。媒体引发偏见的心理学理论可追溯到20世纪50年代,并得到了对照实验的支持。然而,缺乏对媒体对穆斯林偏见影响的全国性研究。关于媒体引发对移民偏见的相关研究未能确立任何联系。此外,研究发现人们以证实既有态度的方式解读新闻,这表明在自由民主国家中,媒体引发的对穆斯林的偏见不太可能存在。在此,我们在来自世界上最包容社会之一(新西兰,样本量N = 16584)的多样化全国样本中,测试新闻曝光与反穆斯林偏见之间的关联。为支持媒体引发的伊斯兰恐惧症这一观点,结果显示,更多的新闻曝光与对穆斯林的愤怒增加以及热情降低都有关联。此外,媒体曝光与反穆斯林偏见之间的关系并不会因政治意识形态而可靠地发生变化,这支持了如下观点:是新闻中对穆斯林的广泛呈现,而非党派媒体偏见,导致了反穆斯林偏见。