Raasck Kyle, Habis Ahmed A, Aoude Ahmed, Simões Leonardo, Barros Fernando, Reindl Rudy, Jarzem Peter
Division of Orthopaedic Surgery, McGill University , Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Instituto de Ortopedia e Traumatologia, Oeste D'Or Hospital , Campo Grande, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
Spinal Cord Ser Cases. 2017 Feb 2;3:16043. doi: 10.1038/scsandc.2016.43. eCollection 2017.
Spontaneous spinal epidural hematoma (SSEH) manifests from blood accumulating in the epidural space, compressing the spinal cord and leading to acute neurological deficits. Standard therapy is decompressive laminectomy, although spontaneous recoveries have been reported. Sub-optimal therapeutic principles contribute to SSEH's 5.7% mortality-which patient will benefit from surgery remains unclear. This study aims to investigate parameters that affect SSEH's progression, outlining a best-practice therapeutic approach.
Literature review yielded 65 cases from 12 studies. Furthermore, 6 cases were presented from our institution. All data were analyzed under American Spinal Injury Association (ASIA) score guidelines.
Fifty percent of SSEH patients do not fully recover. In all, 30% of patients who presented with an ASIA score of A did not improve with surgery, although every SSEH patient who presented at C or D improved. Spontaneous recovery is rare-only 23% of patients were treated conservatively. Seventy-three percent of those made a full recovery, as opposed to the 48% improvement in patients managed surgically. Thirty-three percent of patients managed conservatively had an initial score of A or B, all improving to a score of D or E without surgery. Regardless, conservative management tends toward low-risk presentations. Patients managed conservatively were three times as likely to have an initial score of D than their surgically managed counterparts.
The degree of pre-operative neural deficit is a major prognostic factor. Conservative management has proven effective, although feasible only if spontaneous recovery is manifested. Decompressive laminectomy should continue to remain readily available, given the inverse correlation between operative interval and recovery.
自发性脊髓硬膜外血肿(SSEH)表现为硬膜外间隙积血,压迫脊髓并导致急性神经功能缺损。标准治疗方法是减压性椎板切除术,不过也有自发性恢复的报道。次优的治疗原则导致SSEH的死亡率为5.7%——哪些患者将从手术中获益仍不明确。本研究旨在调查影响SSEH病情进展的参数,概述最佳治疗方法。
文献回顾从12项研究中筛选出65例病例。此外,我们机构提供了6例病例。所有数据均按照美国脊髓损伤协会(ASIA)评分指南进行分析。
50%的SSEH患者未能完全康复。总体而言,ASIA评分为A的患者中有30%手术治疗后并无改善,不过所有ASIA评分为C或D的SSEH患者手术后均有改善。自发性恢复很少见——只有23%的患者接受了保守治疗。其中73%完全康复,相比之下,手术治疗患者的改善率为48%。接受保守治疗的患者中有33%初始评分为A或B,均未手术而改善至D或E级。无论如何,保守治疗往往适用于低风险病例。接受保守治疗的患者初始评分为D的可能性是接受手术治疗患者的三倍。
术前神经功能缺损程度是主要的预后因素。保守治疗已被证明有效,不过只有在出现自发性恢复时才可行。鉴于手术间隔与恢复之间呈负相关,减压性椎板切除术仍应随时可用。