Georgiou George K, Hirvonen Riikka, Manolitsis George, Nurmi Jari-Erik
University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
University of Jyväskylä, Finland.
Br J Educ Psychol. 2017 Sep;87(3):438-455. doi: 10.1111/bjep.12158. Epub 2017 Apr 12.
Task avoidance is a significant predictor of literacy skills. However, it remains unclear whether the relation between the two is reciprocal and whether it is affected by the type of literacy outcome, who is rating children's task avoidance, and the children's gender.
The purpose of this longitudinal study was to examine the cross-lagged relations between teacher and parent ratings of children's task avoidance and different literacy skills.
One hundred and seventy-two Greek children (91 girls, 81 boys) were followed from Grade 1 to Grade 3.
Children were assessed on reading accuracy, reading fluency, and spelling to dictation. Parents and teachers rated the children's task-avoidant behaviour.
Results of structural equation modelling showed that the cross-lagged relations varied as a function of the literacy outcome, who rated the children's task avoidance, and children's gender. Earlier reading and spelling performance predicted subsequent parent-rated task avoidance, but parent-rated task avoidance did not predict subsequent reading and spelling performance (with the exception of spelling in Grade 3). Teacher-rated task avoidance and reading fluency/spelling had a reciprocal relationship over time. In addition, the effects of teacher-rated task avoidance on future spelling were significantly stronger in boys than in girls.
This suggests that poor reading and spelling performance can lead to subsequent task avoidance in both classroom and home situations. The fact that task avoidance permeates across different learning environments is alarming and calls for joint action from both parents and teachers to mitigate its negative impact on learning.
任务回避是读写技能的一个重要预测指标。然而,两者之间的关系是否是相互的,以及它是否受到读写结果类型、对儿童任务回避进行评分的人员以及儿童性别的影响,目前尚不清楚。
这项纵向研究的目的是检验教师和家长对儿童任务回避的评分与不同读写技能之间的交叉滞后关系。
172名希腊儿童(91名女孩,81名男孩)从一年级到三年级被跟踪研究。
对儿童进行阅读准确性、阅读流畅性和听写拼写方面的评估。家长和教师对儿童的任务回避行为进行评分。
结构方程模型的结果表明,交叉滞后关系因读写结果、对儿童任务回避进行评分的人员以及儿童性别而异。早期的阅读和拼写表现预测了随后家长评定的任务回避,但家长评定的任务回避并不能预测随后的阅读和拼写表现(三年级的拼写除外)。随着时间的推移,教师评定的任务回避与阅读流畅性/拼写之间存在相互关系。此外,教师评定的任务回避对未来拼写的影响在男孩中比在女孩中显著更强。
这表明阅读和拼写表现不佳会导致随后在课堂和家庭环境中的任务回避。任务回避在不同学习环境中普遍存在这一事实令人担忧,需要家长和教师共同采取行动,减轻其对学习的负面影响。