Nicholls Gordon Michael Mike, Lawrey Emma, Jones Peter
Adult Emergency Department, Auckland City Hospital, Auckland, New Zealand.
Emerg Med Australas. 2017 Oct;29(5):545-550. doi: 10.1111/1742-6723.12759. Epub 2017 Apr 12.
The primary objective of this study is to quantify how many Auckland region emergency medicine (EM) trainees would like a formal mentoring programme. The secondary objectives were to quantify how many Auckland region EM trainees would like to participate in a formal mentoring programme; to determine trainees' current understanding of mentoring; how trainees prefer mentors to be allocated; why trainees may want a mentor; what mentees perceive would be good qualities in a mentor; and trainees' prior experience with mentoring.
Online survey of EM trainees in the Auckland region in June 2015.
Of 61 potential respondents, 40 (65.6%) respondents replied to the survey. Of the 40, 38 (95%; 95% confidence interval (CI) 82.6-99.5) respondents indicated they would like some form of mentoring system, and of the 38, 25 (65.8%; 95% CI 49.8-78.9) preferred this to be formal. Of the 38, 19 (50%; 95% CI 34.9-65.2) currently wanted assistance obtaining a mentor. Of the 40, 30 (75%; 95% CI 59.6-86.0) are not currently in any form of mentoring relationship. Respondents believed that mentors would be most beneficial in critical incidents, career development and with work/life balance. The attributes participants considered most important in a mentor were respecting confidentiality, being honest and the ability to provide constructive feedback.
Many EM trainees in Auckland want a formal mentoring system and would like a mentor. Appropriate mentor-mentee matching through a formalised voluntary system, with adequate mentor training, may enable the Auckland region to develop a suitable mentoring programme for EM trainees.
本研究的主要目的是量化奥克兰地区有多少急诊医学(EM)实习生希望有一个正式的导师计划。次要目的是量化奥克兰地区有多少EM实习生希望参与一个正式的导师计划;确定实习生目前对导师指导的理解;实习生希望如何分配导师;实习生想要导师的原因; mentees认为导师应具备的良好品质;以及实习生以前的导师指导经历。
2015年6月对奥克兰地区的EM实习生进行在线调查。
在61名潜在受访者中,40名(65.6%)回复了调查。在这40名受访者中,38名(95%;95%置信区间(CI)82.6 - 99.5)表示他们希望有某种形式的导师指导系统,在这38名中,25名(65.8%;95% CI 49.8 - 78.9)希望是正式的。在这38名中,19名(50%;95% CI 34.9 - 65.2)目前希望在寻找导师方面获得帮助。在40名受访者中,30名(75%;95% CI 59.6 - 86.0)目前没有任何形式的导师指导关系。受访者认为导师在重大事件、职业发展和工作/生活平衡方面最有帮助。参与者认为导师最重要的属性是尊重保密性、诚实和提供建设性反馈的能力。
奥克兰的许多EM实习生希望有一个正式的导师指导系统并且希望有一位导师。通过正式的自愿系统进行适当的导师与学员匹配,并提供足够的导师培训,可能会使奥克兰地区为EM实习生制定一个合适的导师指导计划。