Wood Jane, Dennard Sophie
Psychiatry. 2017 Spring;80(1):30-41. doi: 10.1080/00332747.2016.1199185.
Gang membership inherently links to violence, and violent experiences strongly relate to posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), anxiety, and paranoia. Yet to date, gang members' mental health has received little attention, and their paranoia has not been examined. This study, using established measures, assessed street gang and nongang prisoners' levels of violence exposure, symptoms of PTSD, paranoia, and anxiety, forced behavioral control, and segregation in prison.
Participants were 65 (32 gang and 33 nongang) prisoners, recruited using opportunity sampling. Participants provided informed consent and were interviewed individually. Interviews were anonymized to maintain confidentiality. Chi-square and discriminant function analyses were used to compare participants' demographics, segregation levels, mental health symptoms, and to identify predictors of street gang membership.
As compared to nongang prisoners, street gang prisoners have higher levels of exposure to violence, symptoms of paranoia, PTSD, anxiety, and forced control of their behavior in prison. Street gang prisoners were not more likely to be segregated, but they were more likely to belong to ethnic minorities. Street gang prisoners were only found to be younger than nongang prisoners, when other variables were controlled for.
Mental health deserves more attention in gang research. The implications of findings are that gang membership may undermine members' mental health, and/or that individuals with existing mental health problems may be those attracted to gang membership. Moreover, justice responses, via policies and intervention strategies, need to identify and address the mental health needs in gang member prisoners, if successful rehabilitation of gang members is to be achieved.
帮派成员身份与暴力行为有着内在联系,而暴力经历与创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)、焦虑和偏执狂密切相关。然而,迄今为止,帮派成员的心理健康很少受到关注,他们的偏执狂也未得到研究。本研究采用既定的测量方法,评估了街头帮派成员和非帮派囚犯的暴力暴露水平、创伤后应激障碍症状、偏执狂、焦虑、强制行为控制以及在监狱中的隔离情况。
参与者为65名囚犯(32名帮派成员和33名非帮派成员),采用机会抽样法招募。参与者提供了知情同意书,并接受了单独访谈。访谈进行了匿名处理以保持保密性。使用卡方检验和判别函数分析来比较参与者的人口统计学特征、隔离水平、心理健康症状,并确定街头帮派成员身份的预测因素。
与非帮派囚犯相比,街头帮派囚犯在监狱中遭受暴力的程度更高,有偏执狂、创伤后应激障碍、焦虑症状以及行为受到强制控制的情况。街头帮派囚犯被隔离的可能性并不更高,但他们更有可能属于少数族裔。在控制了其他变量后,仅发现街头帮派囚犯比非帮派囚犯更年轻。
心理健康在帮派研究中应得到更多关注。研究结果的意义在于,帮派成员身份可能会损害成员的心理健康,和/或存在心理健康问题的个体可能更容易被吸引加入帮派。此外,如果要成功改造帮派成员,司法应对措施需要通过政策和干预策略来识别并满足帮派成员囚犯的心理健康需求。