1 Division of Surgical Research, University Hospital Zurich, University of Zurich, CH-8091 Zurich, Switzerland.
2 Neuroscience Center Zurich, University of Zurich and ETH Zurich, 8057 Zurich, Switzerland.
Exp Biol Med (Maywood). 2017 Jun;242(12):1287-1298. doi: 10.1177/1535370217707730. Epub 2017 May 5.
Balanced anesthesia allows for a reduced dosage of each component, while inducing general anesthesia of sufficient depth with potentially fewer side effects. Here, we compare two anesthetic protocols combining sevoflurane anesthesia with pre-medication (ketamine [K] or fentanyl-midazolam [FM]) to a sevoflurane monoanesthesia (S) concerning their ability to provide reliable anesthesia suitable for moderate surgery in laboratory mice. Twenty-one female C57BL/6J mice assigned randomly to one of three protocols underwent a 50-min anesthesia and a sham embryo transfer. Heart rate and core body temperature were continuously recorded by telemetry intra-operatively and for three days pre- and three days post-surgery. Intra-operative respiratory rate was determined by counting thorax movements. Body weight, food, and water intake were measured daily for three days pre- and three days post-surgery. The heart rate in the KS group remained at baseline level throughout the 50-min of anesthesia and surgery. FMS caused a lower heart rate and S alone caused a higher heart rate compared to baseline values. Intra-operative body temperature was at baseline levels in all groups. A decreased respiratory rate was observed in all groups compared to baseline values obtained from resting mice of the same strain, sex and age-distribution. Surgical stimuli induced no significant changes in heart rate and respiratory rate in the KS or FMS group but significant respiratory alteration in the S group compared to baseline values obtained 10 s before applying the stimulus. Post-operative heart rate was above baseline values in all groups; with a significant deviation in the S group. There were no changes in body weight, food, and water intake. In summary, FMS was superior to KS and S for moderate surgery in laboratory mice resulting in less inter-individual variability in response to painful stimuli. Fentanyl and midazolam reduced the depressant effect of sevoflurane on the respiratory rate and the negative post-anesthetic effects on the heart rate. Impact statement With approximately 65 million animals used per year mice are still the most prevalent laboratory mammal species worldwide. In course of biomedical research projects approximately 40% of mice will undergo one or more short or long-term anesthesia. Sufficient anesthetic depth, cardiovascular stability, adequate analgesia, and short recovery times are essential requirements of anesthetic protocols to meet animal welfare. Anesthesia in mice and rats are only to be performed by personnel with appropriate basic training and experience. However, more and more adapted and advanced anesthetic protocols, required to answer very specific scientific questions, often exceed the skills acquired through basic training and present a major challenge to researchers. It is therefore of great importance to further develop and evaluate safe and reliable anesthetic protocols as presented in this study to provide new perspectives on this challenging problem.
平衡麻醉可以减少每种成分的剂量,同时在诱导足够深度的全身麻醉时潜在地减少副作用。在这里,我们比较了两种麻醉方案,即将七氟醚麻醉与术前用药(氯胺酮[K]或芬太尼-咪达唑仑[FM])联合使用,与七氟醚单麻醉(S)相比,它们在提供适用于实验室小鼠中度手术的可靠麻醉方面的能力。 21 只雌性 C57BL/6J 小鼠随机分配到三个方案之一,接受 50 分钟麻醉和假胚胎移植。术中通过遥测连续记录心率和核心体温,术前 3 天和术后 3 天,术后 3 天。术中呼吸频率通过计数胸廓运动确定。术前 3 天和术后 3 天每天测量体重、食物和水的摄入量。KS 组的心率在 50 分钟麻醉和手术过程中保持在基线水平。FMS 导致心率降低,而 S 单独导致心率高于基线值。所有组的术中体温均处于基线水平。与同一品系、性别和年龄分布的静息小鼠的基线值相比,所有组的呼吸率均降低。手术刺激在 KS 或 FMS 组中未引起心率和呼吸率的显著变化,但在 S 组中与施加刺激前 10 秒获得的基线值相比,呼吸发生显著改变。所有组术后心率均高于基线值;S 组有显著偏差。体重、食物和水的摄入量没有变化。总之,FMS 优于 KS 和 S,适用于实验室小鼠的中度手术,对疼痛刺激的反应个体间变异性更小。芬太尼和咪达唑仑降低了七氟醚对呼吸率的抑制作用,并减轻了麻醉后对心率的负面影响。
影响评估
每年大约有 6500 万只动物被用于实验,老鼠仍然是世界上最普遍的实验哺乳动物物种。在生物医学研究项目中,大约 40%的老鼠将经历一次或多次短期或长期麻醉。足够的麻醉深度、心血管稳定性、充分的镇痛和短的恢复期是麻醉方案的基本要求,以满足动物福利。老鼠和大鼠的麻醉只能由经过适当基础培训和经验的人员进行。然而,越来越多的适应和先进的麻醉方案,以满足非常具体的科学问题,往往超出了通过基本培训获得的技能,并对研究人员提出了重大挑战。因此,进一步开发和评估本研究中提出的安全可靠的麻醉方案非常重要,这为解决这一具有挑战性的问题提供了新的视角。