Biggs Nicole C, England Benjamin S, Turcotte Nicole J, Cook Melissa R, Williams Alyne L
Division of Health & Human Performance, Exercise Science Department, Indiana Wesleyan University, Marion, IN, USA.
Int J Exerc Sci. 2017 Jan 1;10(1):127-136. doi: 10.70252/BARK5186. eCollection 2017.
Aerobic exercise at altitude has shown an increase in maximal oxygen uptake. Similar effects have been replicated by way of simulated altitude training, which have influenced various advances in the field of exercise science. Elevation Training Masks© (ETM) claim to stimulate cardiorespiratory fitness improvements similar to training at altitude, however, there is little research to support this claim. The purpose of this study was to research the effect that a hypoxia-inducing mask would have on cardiorespiratory fitness and pulmonary function through the use of a high intensity interval training (HIIT) running program. Seventeen subjects were randomized into either the control group, without the mask, or experimental group, with the mask, and participated in a 6-week HIIT protocol of 4 sessions per week. Each session included a warm up, followed by intervals of running at 80% of their heart rate reserve (HRR) for 90 seconds and followed by 3 minutes of active rest at 50-60% of HRR. A total of 6 intervals were completed per session. Within subjects, there was a significant increase in predicted VOmax (F(1,17)=7.376, P<.05). However, there was no significant difference in predicted VOmax between the control and experimental groups (F(1, 17)=3.669, p= .075). Forced inspiratory vital capacity demonstrated no significant difference within subjects (F(1, 17)= .073, p > .05), or between the two groups (F(1, 17)= 3.724, p= .073). Similar to the VOmax results, forced vital capacity demonstrated a significant increase within subjects (F(1, 17)=6.201, p<.05), but there was no significant difference between the control and experimental groups (F(1,17)=3.562, p= .079). Although the between groups data was not significant, there was a greater increase in the experimental group wearing the ETM compared to the control group not wearing the mask for all 3 variables. Data suggest that HIIT training can be a viable method of improving VOmax and pulmonary function however, training masks such as the ETM may not lead to greater overall improvements.
在高原进行有氧运动已显示出最大摄氧量增加。通过模拟高原训练也产生了类似效果,这推动了运动科学领域的各种进展。海拔训练面罩(ETM)声称能刺激心肺适能提升,效果类似于在高原训练,然而,几乎没有研究支持这一说法。本研究的目的是通过高强度间歇训练(HIIT)跑步计划,研究一种诱导低氧的面罩对心肺适能和肺功能的影响。17名受试者被随机分为不戴面罩的对照组或戴面罩的实验组,并参与为期6周、每周4次的HIIT方案。每次训练包括热身,然后以心率储备(HRR)的80%跑步90秒,接着以HRR的50 - 60%进行3分钟的主动休息。每次训练共完成6组间歇。在受试者内部,预测的最大摄氧量有显著增加(F(1,17)=7.376,P<.05)。然而,对照组和实验组之间预测的最大摄氧量没有显著差异(F(1, 17)=3.669,p = .075)。用力吸气肺活量在受试者内部没有显著差异(F(1, 17)= .073,p > .05),两组之间也没有显著差异(F(1, 17)= 3.724,p= .073)。与最大摄氧量结果类似,用力肺活量在受试者内部有显著增加(F(1, 17)=6.201,p<.05),但对照组和实验组之间没有显著差异(F(1,17)=3.562,p = .079)。尽管组间数据不显著,但与不戴面罩的对照组相比,佩戴ETM的实验组在所有3个变量上的增加幅度更大。数据表明,HIIT训练可能是提高最大摄氧量和肺功能的一种可行方法,然而,像ETM这样的训练面罩可能不会带来更大的总体改善。