Fu Jun-Ying, Zhang Xu, Zhao Yun-Hua, Tong He-Feng, Chen Dar-Zen, Huang Mu-Hsuan
Technical Reports Service and Information Research Center, Institute of Scientific and Technical Information of China, Beijing, P.R. China.
Department of Mechanical Engineering and Institute of Industrial Engineering, National Taiwan University, Taipei, Taiwan.
Afr J Tradit Complement Altern Med. 2017 Mar 1;14(3):257-273. doi: 10.21010/ajtcam.v14i3.27. eCollection 2017.
Considerable research has been conducted on acupuncture worldwide. This study chronologically examined the changing features and research fronts of acupuncture and elucidated the differences among the six most productive countries.
Bibliographic coupling is a powerful tool for identifying the research fronts of a field. Acupuncture-related publications worldwide and from the six most productive countries during 1983-2012 were retrieved from the Science Citation Index Expanded and Social Science Citation Index. To form the research fronts, the 100 most highly cited papers (HCPs) were clustered in terms of references shared.
The United States had the highest proportion of HCPs. The effectiveness of acupuncture in areas such as relieving neck and back pain, migraines and headaches, and knee osteoarthritis symptoms was a predominant topic. Initially, the endogenous opioid peptide system was the primary research focus in the acupuncture mechanism research; however, during 1993-2012, researchers focused more on the functional magnetic resonance imaging of brain activity. In addition, acupuncture use and prevalence, the attitudes of health practitioners, and the effects of expectancy and belief were also major topics. Researches from Western countries, including the United States, England, and Germany, showed more interest in clinical trials and economic- and ethics-related studies, whereas those from East Asian countries including China, Japan, and South Korea focused more on mechanism research.
Western countries dominated the research fronts of acupuncture. The patterns of the research fronts varied worldwide, indicating continuity and innovation in research in each country.
全球范围内对针灸已开展了大量研究。本研究按时间顺序考察了针灸研究的变化特征和前沿领域,并阐明了六个针灸研究成果最多的国家之间的差异。
文献耦合是识别一个领域研究前沿的有力工具。从《科学引文索引扩展版》和《社会科学引文索引》中检索了1983 - 2012年全球及六个针灸研究成果最多的国家的针灸相关出版物。为形成研究前沿,将100篇被引频次最高的论文(HCPs)按共享参考文献进行聚类。
美国的HCPs占比最高。针灸在缓解颈部和背部疼痛、偏头痛和头痛以及膝关节骨关节炎症状等方面的有效性是一个主要研究主题。最初,内源性阿片肽系统是针灸机制研究的主要焦点;然而,在1993 - 2012年期间,研究人员更多地关注大脑活动的功能磁共振成像。此外,针灸的使用和普及情况、健康从业者的态度以及期望和信念的影响也是主要研究主题。包括美国、英国和德国在内的西方国家的研究对临床试验以及经济和伦理相关研究表现出更大兴趣,而包括中国、日本和韩国在内的东亚国家的研究则更多地聚焦于机制研究。
西方国家主导了针灸的研究前沿领域。研究前沿模式在全球范围内各不相同,表明每个国家的研究具有连续性和创新性。