Arroll Bruce, Henwood Suzanne M, Sundram Fred I, Kingsford Douglas W, Mount Vicki, Humm Steve P, Wallace Henry B, Pillai Avinesh
1 Department of General Practice and Primary Health Care, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
2 Unitec Institute of Technology, Auckland, New Zealand.
Int J Psychiatry Med. 2017 Jan;52(1):21-33. doi: 10.1177/0091217417703285. Epub 2017 Apr 7.
Objective To assess the effectiveness of a novel imaginal intervention for people with acrophobia. Methods The design was a randomized controlled trial with concealed randomization and blinded to other participants' intervention. The intervention was a single novel imaginal intervention session or a 15-min meditation. The setting was in Auckland, New Zealand. The participants were a convenience sample of the public with a score >29 on the Heights Interpretation Questionnaire (HIQ), a questionnaire validated against actual height exposure. The primary outcomes were the proportion of participants with a score <26 on the HIQ at eight weeks and difference between the HIQ scores between the two arms of the study. Results Ninety-eight participants (92%) returned their questionnaire and were included in the intention to treat analysis. The HIQ score <26 was 34.6% (18/52) in the intervention group and 15.2% (7/46) in the control group RR = 2.26, 95% CI (1.05, 4.95) and p = 0.028. The numbers needed to treat is six 95% CI (3 to 36). Participants with scores <26 report their fear of heights is very much improved. There was a 4.5-point difference in the HIQ score at eight weeks (p = 0.055) on the multiple regression analysis. Conclusions This is the first randomized trial of this novel imaginal intervention which is probably effective, brief, easily learnt, and safe. It may be worth considering doing this prior to some of the longer or more expensive exposure therapies. This study will be of interest to family doctors, psychiatrists, and psychologists.
目的 评估一种针对恐高症患者的新型想象干预措施的有效性。方法 采用随机对照试验设计,随机分组过程保密,且对其他参与者的干预情况设盲。干预措施为单次新型想象干预疗程或15分钟的冥想。研究地点在新西兰奥克兰。参与者是从公众中便利抽样选取的,在高度解读问卷(HIQ)上得分>29分,该问卷已通过实际高度暴露验证。主要结局指标为八周时HIQ得分<26分的参与者比例以及研究两组间HIQ得分的差异。结果 98名参与者(92%)返还了问卷并纳入意向性分析。干预组HIQ得分<26分的比例为34.6%(18/52),对照组为15.2%(7/46),相对危险度RR = 2.26,95%可信区间(1.05,4.95),p = 0.028。需治疗人数为6,95%可信区间(3至36)。得分<26分的参与者报告其恐高情况有很大改善。多元回归分析显示八周时HIQ得分有4.5分的差异(p = 0.055)。结论 这是首次对这种新型想象干预措施进行的随机试验,该措施可能有效、简短、易于学习且安全。在进行一些更长时间或更昂贵的暴露疗法之前,或许值得考虑采用这种方法。家庭医生、精神科医生和心理学家可能会对这项研究感兴趣。