Suppr超能文献

新加坡医学本科头痛教育调查:知识、认知及未满足需求评估

Medical Undergraduate Survey on Headache Education in Singapore: Knowledge, Perceptions, and Assessment of Unmet Needs.

作者信息

Ong Jonathan Jia Yuan, Chan Yee Cheun

机构信息

Division of Neurology, Department of Medicine, National University Hospital, Singapore.

出版信息

Headache. 2017 Jun;57(6):967-978. doi: 10.1111/head.13110. Epub 2017 May 9.

Abstract

BACKGROUND

There have been no prior studies assessing the status of undergraduate headache training and education in Singapore. Unmet needs of undergraduate medical students in terms of knowledge-practice gaps pertaining to diagnosis and management of headache disorders are unknown. The possible underemphasis of this aspect of the curriculum as compared to other chronic conditions such as diabetes mellitus has also not been ascertained.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this article is to assess the knowledge base and perceptions, thereby identifying the unmet needs of headache disorder education in undergraduate medical students. Students reported their perceived time that was devoted to the subject matter and this was recorded and reported. In order to provide a comparative indication on the level of prioritization, the total duration within the syllabus dedicated to headache education vs other chronic diseases (using diabetes mellitus as a surrogate) was sought.

METHODS

A comprehensive survey consisting of questions assessing the headache curriculum, knowledge, and perceptions was developed. The questionnaire was distributed to final year medical students attending a full-day Neurology review course in their last semester. Attendees were given the duration of the course to complete the questionnaire, and forms were collected at the end of the day.

RESULTS

About 127 final year medical students completed our survey. More than half (55.1%) did not receive formal teaching on how to take a complete headache history. The majority (90.6%) have not attended a headache sub-specialty clinic. The mean total number of hours exposed to headache disorders was 5.69h (SD ± 5.19). The vast majority (96.1%) were unfamiliar with locally published clinical practice guidelines, and a significant proportion (74.0%) were unfamiliar with the third edition (beta) of the International Classification of Headache Disorders. Nearly half (47.2%) were unfamiliar with 'medication overuse headache' as a disease entity. Only one (0.8%) respondent was able to correctly classify all listed primary and secondary headache disorders correctly. Only 37.0% were able to identify all 4 indications (headaches that were new, worsening, and unresponsive to treatment or associated with neurological symptoms) that warranted neuroimaging in a patient with a pre-existing diagnosis of migraine. The antidepressants were the most frequently reported incorrect option for the abortive treatment of migraine (16.5%). Nearly one-fifth (18.9%) were unable to name a single abortive treatment correctly, while a significant proportion (39.4%) could not identify a single correct prophylactic migraine treatment. A large proportion (62.2%) opined that their exposure to 'headache diagnosis and management' was inadequate, with a minority (3.1%) being 'very comfortable' in the diagnosing migraine. A significant proportion felt uncomfortable in treating special population groups diagnosed with migraine - pregnant (79.5%), elderly (48.0%), those with cardiac conditions (51.2%).

CONCLUSIONS

The current medical undergraduate curriculum on headache disorders in Singapore may harbor significant unmet needs. A review of the syllabus to increase headache education may be one method to address this gap. Further studies in this area are required.

摘要

背景

此前尚无研究评估新加坡本科阶段头痛症培训与教育的现状。本科医学生在头痛症诊断与管理方面知识与实践差距的未满足需求尚不明确。与糖尿病等其他慢性病相比,该课程这一方面可能未得到足够重视的情况也未得到确定。

目的

本文旨在评估本科医学生的知识基础和认知,从而确定头痛症教育方面未满足的需求。学生报告了他们认为用于该主题的时间,对此进行了记录和报告。为了提供关于优先程度的比较指标,还查询了教学大纲中专门用于头痛症教育与其他慢性病(以糖尿病作为替代)的总时长。

方法

编制了一份全面的调查问卷,其中包含评估头痛症课程、知识和认知的问题。问卷分发给了最后一学期参加全天神经病学复习课程的本科四年级医学生。参加者有课程时长来完成问卷,当天结束时收集问卷。

结果

约127名本科四年级医学生完成了我们的调查。超过半数(55.1%)的学生未接受过关于如何完整采集头痛病史的正规教学。大多数(90.6%)学生未去过头痛症专科门诊。接触头痛症的平均总时长为5.69小时(标准差±5.19)。绝大多数(96.1%)学生不熟悉本地发布的临床实践指南,相当一部分(74.0%)学生不熟悉《国际头痛疾病分类》第三版(试用版)。近半数(47.2%)学生不熟悉“药物过量使用性头痛”这一疾病实体。只有一名(0.8%)受访者能够正确分类所有列出的原发性和继发性头痛症。只有37.0%的学生能够识别出偏头痛患者进行神经影像学检查所需的全部4种指征(新发、加重、对治疗无反应或伴有神经症状的头痛)。抗抑郁药是偏头痛预防性治疗中最常被错误选择的药物(16.5%)。近五分之一(18.9%)的学生无法正确说出一种预防性治疗药物,相当一部分(39.4%)学生无法识别出一种正确的偏头痛预防性治疗药物。很大一部分(62.2%)学生认为他们对“头痛症诊断与管理”的接触不足,少数(3.1%)学生对诊断偏头痛“非常有信心”。很大一部分学生对治疗被诊断为偏头痛的特殊人群感到不自在——孕妇(79.5%)、老年人(48.0%)、患有心脏疾病的人(51.2%)。

结论

新加坡目前的本科医学课程中关于头痛症的内容可能存在重大未满足需求。审查教学大纲以增加头痛症教育可能是弥补这一差距的一种方法。该领域还需要进一步研究。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验