Yuan L, Ge Y, Li T, Yin F, Wu Q Jackie
Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC.
Wake Forest University Health Sciences, Winston-Salem, NC.
Med Phys. 2012 Jun;39(6Part20):3850. doi: 10.1118/1.4735716.
We present an evidence-based approach to quantifying the dose sparing trade-offs between different Organs-at-risk (OARs) and the trade-off between OAR dose sparing and target dose coverage in IMRT plans.
The interaction between dose sparing of different OARs and between target dose coverage and OAR dose sparing are modeled using high-quality prior IMRT plans of prostate, head-and-neck (HN), and spine SBRT cases. The dose sparing for each OAR is modeled separately at first based on their own anatomical features and then the contributions from other OARs or PTV are added into the model to account for the possible trade-off effects in plans whose modeled OAR DVH deviates from that of actual plans.
The most significant OAR dose sparing trade-off is between bladder and rectum in prostate plans and between the left and the right parotids in HN plans. Trade-off is most apparent when the parotid on one side has very large overlap with the PTV. In most of these plans (83%), the planer chooses to loosen the dose constraint for that parotid in exchange for lower contra-lateral parotid median dose. The interaction between OAR dose sparing and PTV dose coverage is most significant in spine SBRT plans, (R2=0.37). Another important factor is the tightness of the geometric enclosure of PTV around OAR (R2=0.38).
The dosimetric trade-off between multiple OARs and between PTV and OAR in IMRT planning is quantified by studying prior plans. These findings will help physicians and planners obtain better OAR dose sparing by exploring different trade-off options for individual patient cases. Partially supported by a master research agreement with Varian Medical Systems, Inc.
我们提出一种基于证据的方法,用于量化调强放射治疗(IMRT)计划中不同危及器官(OARs)之间的剂量节省权衡,以及OAR剂量节省与靶区剂量覆盖之间的权衡。
利用前列腺、头颈部(HN)和脊柱立体定向放射治疗(SBRT)病例的高质量既往IMRT计划,对不同OARs的剂量节省之间以及靶区剂量覆盖与OAR剂量节省之间的相互作用进行建模。首先根据每个OAR自身的解剖特征分别对其剂量节省进行建模,然后将其他OARs或计划靶体积(PTV)的贡献添加到模型中,以考虑模型中OAR剂量体积直方图(DVH)与实际计划不同的计划中可能存在的权衡效应。
在前列腺计划中,膀胱和直肠之间以及在HN计划中左右腮腺之间的OAR剂量节省权衡最为显著。当一侧腮腺与PTV有很大重叠时,权衡最为明显。在大多数这些计划(83%)中,计划制定者选择放宽对该腮腺的剂量限制以换取对侧腮腺更低的中位剂量。在脊柱SBRT计划中,OAR剂量节省与PTV剂量覆盖之间的相互作用最为显著(R2 = 0.37)。另一个重要因素是PTV围绕OAR的几何包绕紧密程度(R2 = 0.38)。
通过研究既往计划,对IMRT计划中多个OARs之间以及PTV与OAR之间的剂量学权衡进行了量化。这些发现将有助于医生和计划制定者通过为个体患者病例探索不同的权衡选项来更好地实现OAR剂量节省。部分得到与瓦里安医疗系统公司的主研究协议的支持。