Grisaru Nimrod, Budowski Danny, Ayecheh Seffefe, Witztum Eliezer
The Beer Sheva Mental Health Center; Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Israel.
Mental Health Division, Israeli Ministry of Health.
Harefuah. 2016 Dec;155(12):741-744.
The psychiatric classifications of disease (DSMIV; ICD-10) relate to a family of high incidence somatoform disorders whose use isn't uniform and cannot be measured. DSM-5 presents the term "cultural conceptualization of distress", which attempts to describe the cultural construct and its influences on mental distress and symptom presentation. Somatization among immigrants poses a diagnostic, treatment and research challenge due to cultural differences such as wrong understanding of their symptoms that may lead to misdiagnosis and to prescribing wrong and possibly harmful treatment and unnecessary hospitalization. This challenge is greater when encountering Ethiopian new immigrants due to the significant doctor-patient cultural gaps on one hand, and the community's heterogeneity, on the other. The Integrative Culture Sensitive Assessment and Treatment Model helps structure the diagnostic and treatment processes appropriately.
Two culture-related functional somatic disorders are presented, alongside with their diagnosis and treatment: The "Ken-Ken" syndrome (worms in the ear) - where the patient complains worms have entered her ear and head influencing her daily functioning, and the "prolonged pregnancy" syndrome, where the menopausal woman believes she is pregnant for many years and that the fetus "has turned into bone".
This article presents the somatization mechanism via two culture-related case studies of Ethiopian new immigrants to Israel suffering from emotional distress via culturally different symptomatology. It further presents an integrated cultural oriented treatment approach as a way to reduce overuse of primary and secondary medical services.
疾病的精神病学分类(《精神疾病诊断与统计手册第四版》;《国际疾病分类第十版》)涉及一系列高发性躯体形式障碍,其使用并不统一且无法衡量。《精神疾病诊断与统计手册第五版》提出了“痛苦的文化概念化”这一术语,试图描述文化建构及其对精神痛苦和症状表现的影响。移民中的躯体化现象给诊断、治疗和研究带来了挑战,因为文化差异,比如对自身症状的错误理解,可能导致误诊以及开出错误且可能有害的治疗方案和不必要的住院治疗。当遇到埃塞俄比亚新移民时,这一挑战更大,一方面是医患之间存在显著的文化差距,另一方面是社区的异质性。综合文化敏感评估与治疗模型有助于恰当地构建诊断和治疗过程。
介绍了两种与文化相关的功能性躯体障碍及其诊断和治疗:“肯 - 肯”综合征(耳中有虫)——患者抱怨有虫子进入她的耳朵和头部,影响其日常功能;以及“长期妊娠”综合征,更年期女性认为自己怀孕多年,且胎儿“已变成骨头”。
本文通过两个与文化相关的案例研究,呈现了埃塞俄比亚新移民到以色列后因文化上不同的症状表现而遭受情绪困扰的躯体化机制。文章还进一步提出了一种综合的文化导向治疗方法,作为减少初级和二级医疗服务过度使用的一种方式。