College of Pharmacy, Qatar University, Doha, Qatar.
College of Pharmacy, Qatar University, Doha, Qatar.
Res Social Adm Pharm. 2018 Apr;14(4):391-397. doi: 10.1016/j.sapharm.2017.05.003. Epub 2017 May 10.
Nonadherence to medications in patients with diabetes, which results in poor treatment outcomes and increased healthcare costs, is commonly reported globally. Factors associated with medication adherence have also been widely studied. However, a clear and comprehensive, disease-specific conceptual framework model that captures all possible factors has not been established.
This study aimed to develop a conceptual framework that addresses the complex network of barriers to medication adherence in patients with diabetes.
Fourteen databases and grey literature sources were systematically searched for systematic reviews reporting barriers to medication adherence in patients with diabetes. A thematic approach was used to categorize all identified barriers from the reviews and to create a matrix representing the complex network and relations of the different barriers.
Eighteen systematic reviews were identified and used for the development of the conceptual framework. Overall, six major themes emerged: patient-, medication-, disease-, provider-, system-, and societal-related factors. Each of these themes was further classified into different sub-categories. It was noted that most interactions were identified to be within the patient-related factors, which not only interact with other themes but also within the same theme. Patient's demographics as well as cultural beliefs were the most notable factors in terms of interactions with other categories and themes.
The intricate network and interaction of factors identified between different themes and within individual themes indicate the complexity of the problem of adherence. This framework will potentially enhance the understanding of the complex relation between different barriers for medication adherence in diabetes and will facilitate design of more effective interventions. Future interventions for enhancing medication adherence should look at the overall factors and target multiple themes of barriers to improve patient outcomes.
糖尿病患者不遵医嘱服药的现象较为普遍,这导致治疗效果不佳和医疗成本增加。全球范围内已有大量研究报道了与药物依从性相关的因素。然而,目前尚未建立一个全面、综合且针对特定疾病的概念框架模型来捕捉所有可能的因素。
本研究旨在开发一个概念框架,以解决糖尿病患者药物依从性障碍的复杂网络问题。
系统检索了 14 个数据库和灰色文献来源,以获取报告糖尿病患者药物依从性障碍的系统评价。采用主题分析方法对所有综述中确定的障碍进行分类,并创建一个矩阵,以表示不同障碍之间的复杂网络和关系。
共确定了 18 篇系统评价,并用于概念框架的开发。总体而言,出现了六个主要主题:患者、药物、疾病、提供者、系统和社会相关因素。每个主题进一步分为不同的子类别。值得注意的是,大多数相互作用发生在患者相关因素内,这些因素不仅与其他主题相互作用,而且在同一主题内也相互作用。患者的人口统计学特征以及文化信仰是与其他类别和主题相互作用最显著的因素。
不同主题之间以及单个主题内确定的因素之间错综复杂的网络和相互作用表明了依从性问题的复杂性。该框架将有助于增强对糖尿病患者药物依从性障碍之间复杂关系的理解,并促进设计更有效的干预措施。未来提高药物依从性的干预措施应着眼于整体因素,并针对多个障碍主题进行干预,以改善患者的结局。