Morgan Susan, Plaisant Odile, Lignier Baptiste, Moxham Bernard J
Cardiff School of English, Communication and Philosophy, Cardiff University, Cardiff, CF10 3EU, United Kingdom.
University of Paris Descartes, Sorbonne Paris Cite, ANCRE, URDIA, EA 4465, Paris, France.
Clin Anat. 2017 Sep;30(6):711-732. doi: 10.1002/ca.22922. Epub 2017 Jun 19.
Previous studies suggest that, while both medical students and professional anatomists recognize the importance of gender issues and do not wish to associate with sexism, most are unaware of the possible negative aspects of sexism within anatomy (Morgan et al. , J. Anat. 224:352-365; , Clin. Anat. 29:892-910). To further investigate this issue, we provided second year medical students at Cardiff University (n = 293) and at the University of Paris Descartes, Sorbonne Paris Cité (n = 142) and professional anatomists (n = 208) with a questionnaire inviting them to address the possibility that gender factors within anatomical imagery (both historical and contemporary) hinder the dispassionate representation of anatomy. Ethical approval for the survey was obtained from the universities at both Cardiff and Paris. In the light of previous findings, the hypothesis tested was that medical students and professional anatomists do not perceive a gender bias when reflected in imagery that is based on anatomical iconography. Our survey results support this hypothesis and suggest that most students and anatomists are unaware of the possible negative aspects of sexism within the culture of anatomy. We consequently recommend that teachers of anatomy and authors of anatomical textbooks should be aware of the possibility of adverse effects on professional matters relating to equality and diversity issues when using imagery. Clin. Anat. 30:711-732, 2017. © 2017Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
以往的研究表明,虽然医学生和专业解剖学家都认识到性别问题的重要性,并且不希望与性别歧视联系在一起,但大多数人并未意识到解剖学中性别歧视可能存在的负面影响(Morgan等人,《解剖学杂志》224:352 - 365;《临床解剖学》29:892 - 910)。为了进一步研究这个问题,我们向卡迪夫大学(n = 293)、巴黎笛卡尔大学、索邦巴黎西岱大学(n = 142)的二年级医学生以及专业解剖学家(n = 208)发放了一份问卷,邀请他们探讨解剖学图像(包括历史和当代图像)中的性别因素是否会妨碍对解剖学进行客观呈现。该调查获得了卡迪夫和巴黎两所大学的伦理批准。根据以往的研究结果,所检验的假设是医学生和专业解剖学家在基于解剖图标学的图像中不会察觉到性别偏见。我们的调查结果支持了这一假设,并表明大多数学生和解剖学家并未意识到解剖学文化中性别歧视可能存在的负面影响。因此,我们建议解剖学教师和解剖学教科书的作者在使用图像时应意识到这可能会对与平等和多样性问题相关的专业事务产生不利影响。《临床解剖学》30:711 - 732,2017年。© 2017威利期刊公司