Waldvogel Michael, Gould Fred
Department of Entomology, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC, 27695, USA.
Evolution. 1990 Aug;44(5):1326-1337. doi: 10.1111/j.1558-5646.1990.tb05235.x.
When cotton, geranium, petunia, tobacco, tomato, and velvetleaf were presented simultaneously to strains of the Heliothine moth, Heliothis virescens (F.), from Arizona (AZ), Mississippi (MS), and North Carolina (NC), oviposition choices were similar, while a strain from the Virgin Islands (VI) was significantly different from both the AZ and MS strains. In the MS-VI six-host test, the VI strain laid a higher proportion of its eggs on tomato and a lower proportion of its eggs on petunia than did the MS strain. Since petunia and tomato are in the same plant family (Solanaceae), differences between the strains in host preference do not appear to involve traits common to all members of a plant family. In the AZ-VI six-host test, the AZ strain laid a higher percentage of its eggs on tobacco and lower percentages on geranium and velvetleaf (Malvaceae) than did the VI strain. The percentages of eggs laid on cotton (Malvaceae) by the two strains were not significantly different. When moths were placed in cages with only tobacco and geranium, the AZ strain again laid a higher percentage of its eggs on tobacco than did the VI strain. However, when host choice was restricted to tobacco and cotton or velvetleaf and cotton, no significant difference between strains was found. Reciprocal hybrids of the AZ and VI strains were intermediate to the parental stocks in their preference for tobacco over geranium, indicating that a genetic mechanism was responsible for oviposition preference. The relevance of these findings to seemingly rapid fluxes in host range among members of the Heliothinae is discussed.
当同时向来自亚利桑那州(AZ)、密西西比州(MS)和北卡罗来纳州(NC)的棉铃虫(Heliothis virescens (F.))品系提供棉花、天竺葵、矮牵牛、烟草、番茄和苘麻时,产卵选择相似,而来自维尔京群岛(VI)的一个品系与AZ和MS品系有显著差异。在MS - VI的六种寄主测试中,VI品系在番茄上产的卵比例高于MS品系,而在矮牵牛上产的卵比例低于MS品系。由于矮牵牛和番茄属于同一植物科(茄科),品系间寄主偏好的差异似乎并不涉及植物科所有成员共有的特征。在AZ - VI的六种寄主测试中,AZ品系在烟草上产的卵百分比高于VI品系,而在天竺葵和苘麻(锦葵科)上产的卵百分比低于VI品系。两个品系在棉花(锦葵科)上产的卵百分比没有显著差异。当将蛾子置于仅含有烟草和天竺葵的笼子中时,AZ品系在烟草上产的卵百分比再次高于VI品系。然而,当寄主选择仅限于烟草和棉花或苘麻和棉花时,未发现品系间有显著差异。AZ和VI品系的正反交杂种在对烟草和天竺葵的偏好上介于亲本之间,这表明产卵偏好是由遗传机制决定的。本文讨论了这些发现与棉铃虫亚科成员寄主范围看似快速变化的相关性。