Freire Raul, Farinatti Paulo, Cunha Felipe, Silva Brenno, Monteiro Walace
Physical Activity Sciences Graduate Program, Salgado de Oliveira University, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
Laboratory of Physical Activity and Health Promotion, Rio de Janeiro State University, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
Int J Sports Med. 2017 Jul;38(7):515-520. doi: 10.1055/s-0043-101913. Epub 2017 May 31.
This study investigated cardiorespiratory responses and rating of perceived exertion (RPE) during prolonged walking and running exercise performed at the walk-run transition speed (WRTS) in untrained healthy elderly men. 20 volunteers (mean±SE, age: 68.4±1.2 yrs; height: 170.0±0.02 cm; body mass: 74.7±2.3 kg) performed the following bouts of exercise: a) maximal cardiopulmonary exercise test (CPET); b) specific protocol to detect WRTS; and c) two 30-min walking and running bouts at WRTS. Expired gases were collected during exercise bouts via the Ultima CardiO metabolic analyzer. Compared to walking, running at the WRTS resulted in higher oxygen uptake (>0.27 L·min), pulmonary ventilation (>7.7 L·min), carbon dioxide output (>0.23 L·min), heart rate (>15 beats·min), oxygen pulse (>0.88 15 mL·beats), energy expenditure (>27 kcal) and cost of oxygen transport (>43 mL·kg·km·bout). The increase of overall and local RPEs with exercise duration was similar across locomotion modes (P<0.001). In all participants, %HRR and %VOR throughout walking and running bouts were around or above the gas exchange threshold. In conclusion, elderly men exhibited higher cardiorespiratory responses during 30-min bouts of running than walking at WRTS. Nevertheless, walking corresponded to relative metabolic intensities compatible with preservation or improvement of cardiorespiratory fitness and should be preferable over running at WRTS in the untrained elderly characterized by poor fitness and reduced exercise tolerance.
本研究调查了未经训练的健康老年男性在以走跑转换速度(WRTS)进行长时间步行和跑步运动时的心肺反应及主观用力程度(RPE)评级。20名志愿者(平均值±标准误,年龄:68.4±1.2岁;身高:170.0±0.02厘米;体重:74.7±2.3千克)进行了以下运动试验:a)最大心肺运动试验(CPET);b)检测WRTS的特定方案;c)以WRTS进行两次30分钟的步行和跑步试验。在运动试验期间,通过Ultima CardiO代谢分析仪收集呼出气体。与步行相比,以WRTS跑步导致更高的摄氧量(>0.27升·分钟)、肺通气量(>7.7升·分钟)、二氧化碳排出量(>0.23升·分钟)、心率(>15次·分钟)、氧脉搏(>0.88毫升·次)、能量消耗(>27千卡)和氧运输成本(>43毫升·千克·千米·试验)。不同运动模式下,总体和局部RPE随运动持续时间的增加情况相似(P<0.001)。在所有参与者中,步行和跑步试验期间的心率储备百分比(%HRR)和通气储备百分比(%VOR)均在气体交换阈值左右或之上。总之,老年男性在以WRTS进行30分钟跑步试验时表现出比步行更高的心肺反应。然而,步行对应的相对代谢强度与心肺适能的维持或改善相适应,对于健康状况不佳和运动耐力降低的未经训练的老年人来说,在WRTS下步行应比跑步更可取。