Clark Richard E, Polydoros Fotios, Apperley Jane F, Milojkovic Dragana, Pocock Christopher, Smith Graeme, Byrne Jenny L, de Lavallade Hugues, O'Brien Stephen G, Coffey Tony, Foroni Letizia, Copland Mhairi
Institute of Translational Medicine, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK.
Cancer Research UK Liverpool Cancer Trials Unit, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK.
Lancet Haematol. 2017 Jul;4(7):e310-e316. doi: 10.1016/S2352-3026(17)30066-2. Epub 2017 May 26.
Discontinuation of tyrosine kinase inhibitor (TKI) therapy is feasible for some patients with chronic myeloid leukaemia with deep molecular responses; however, patients with stable major molecular response (MMR), but not MR4, have not been studied, nor has the effect of treatment de-escalation rather than outright cessation. We aimed to examine the effects of treatment de-escalation as a prelude to complete cessation, not only in patients with MR4 or greater, but also in those with MMR but not MR4.
We did this interim analysis of a non-randomised, phase 2 trial at 20 hospitals in the UK. We recruited patients (aged ≥18 years) with chronic myeloid leukaemia in first chronic phase who had received TKI for 3 years or more and were either in stable MR4 (BCR-ABL1:ABL1 ratio <0·01%; MR4 cohort) or in stable MMR (BCR-ABL1:ABL1 ratio consistently <0·1%) but not MR4 (MMR cohort) for 12 months or longer. Participants received half their standard TKI dose (imatinib 200 mg daily, dasatinib 50 mg daily, or nilotinib 200 mg twice daily) for 12 months. Molecular recurrence was defined as loss of MMR (BCR-ABL1:ABL1 ratio >0·1%) on two consecutive samples. The primary endpoint of this interim analysis was the proportion of patients who lost MMR on de-escalation and regained MMR on TKI resumption. Analyses were by intention to treat. This study is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT01804985.
Between Dec 16, 2013 and April 10, 2015, we enrolled 174 patients into the MMR cohort (n=49) or the MR4 cohort (n=125). During the 12 months of half-dose therapy, 12 patients (7%) had molecular recurrence, all of whom regained MMR within 4 months of full-dose TKI resumption (median time to recovery 77 days). Recurrence was significantly lower in the MR4 cohort (three [2%; 90% CI 0·2-4·8] of 121 evaluable patients) than in the MMR cohort (nine [19%; 90% CI 9·5-28·0] of 48 evaluable patients; hazard ratio 0·12, 90% CI 0·04-0·37; p=0·0007), but was unrelated to previous TKI or TKI therapy duration. Adverse events (eg, lethargy, diarrhoea, rash, and nausea) improved during the first 3 months of de-escalation, though not thereafter. 16 serious adverse events were reported, including one fatality due to worsening pre-existing peripheral arterial occlusive disease in a patient who had received only imatinib.
TKI de-escalation is safe for most patients with excellent responses to TKI therapy, and is associated with improvement in symptoms. These findings show that lower TKI doses might maintain responses in these patients, implying that such patients could be unnecessarily overtreated. Studies of more ambitious de-escalation are warranted.
Newcastle University and Bloodwise.
对于一些获得深度分子反应的慢性髓性白血病患者,停用酪氨酸激酶抑制剂(TKI)治疗是可行的;然而,尚未对处于稳定主要分子反应(MMR)但未达到MR4的患者进行研究,治疗降阶梯而非直接停药的效果也未得到研究。我们旨在研究治疗降阶梯作为完全停药前奏的效果,不仅针对达到MR4或更高水平的患者,也针对处于MMR但未达到MR4的患者。
我们对英国20家医院进行的一项非随机2期试验进行了期中分析。我们招募了年龄≥18岁、处于慢性髓性白血病慢性期、接受TKI治疗3年或更长时间、处于稳定MR4(BCR-ABL1:ABL1比值<0.01%;MR4队列)或稳定MMR(BCR-ABL1:ABL1比值持续<0.1%)但未达到MR4(MMR队列)且持续12个月或更长时间的患者。参与者接受标准TKI剂量的一半(伊马替尼每日200 mg、达沙替尼每日50 mg或尼洛替尼每日200 mg,分两次服用),持续12个月。分子复发定义为连续两个样本中MMR丧失(BCR-ABL1:ABL1比值>0.1%)。本次期中分析的主要终点是降阶梯时丧失MMR且恢复TKI治疗后重新获得MMR的患者比例。分析采用意向性分析。本研究已在ClinicalTrials.gov注册,编号为NCT01804985。
在2013年12月16日至2015年4月10日期间,我们将174例患者纳入MMR队列(n = 49)或MR4队列(n = 125)。在半剂量治疗的12个月期间,12例患者(7%)出现分子复发,所有患者在恢复全剂量TKI治疗后4个月内重新获得MMR(恢复的中位时间为77天)。MR4队列中复发率显著低于MMR队列(121例可评估患者中有3例[2%;90%CI 0.2 - 4.8],48例可评估患者中有9例[19%;90%CI 9.5 - 28.0];风险比0.12,90%CI 0.04 - 0.37;p = 0.0007),但与既往TKI或TKI治疗持续时间无关。在降阶梯治疗的前3个月,不良事件(如乏力、腹泻、皮疹和恶心)有所改善,但此后未改善。报告了16例严重不良事件,包括1例因既往存在的外周动脉闭塞性疾病恶化导致的死亡,该患者仅接受了伊马替尼治疗。
对于大多数对TKI治疗反应良好的患者,TKI降阶梯是安全的,且与症状改善相关。这些发现表明较低的TKI剂量可能维持这些患者的反应,这意味着此类患者可能接受了不必要的过度治疗。有必要开展更具挑战性的降阶梯研究。
纽卡斯尔大学和Bloodwise。