Roberts Keith J, Prasad Pooja, Steele Yvonne, Marcon Francesca, Faulkner Thomas, Cilliers Hentie, Dasari Bobby, Abradelo Manuel, Marudanayagam Ravi, Sutcliffe Robert P, Muiesan Paolo, Mirza Darius F, Isaac John
Departments of Pancreatic Surgery and Anaesthesia, University Hospitals Birmingham, UK.
Departments of Pancreatic Surgery and Anaesthesia, University Hospitals Birmingham, UK.
HPB (Oxford). 2017 Aug;19(8):713-720. doi: 10.1016/j.hpb.2017.04.011. Epub 2017 May 26.
Pancreatoduodenectomy (PD) typically follows preoperative biliary drainage (PBD) despite PBD being potentially harmful. This study evaluated a pathway to avoid PBD within the framework of the UK's NHS.
A prospective observational study of jaundiced patients undergoing PD for periampullary cancer. A pathway to provide early surgery without PBD was introduced at the start of the study period.
Over 12 months 61 and 32 patients underwent surgery with and without PBD respectively; 95% of patients in the PBD group had been stented before referral. The time from CT scan to surgery was shorter in the no PBD group (16 vs 65 days, p < 0.0001). Significantly more patients underwent PD in the no PBD group (31/32 vs 46/61, p = 0.009) and venous resection (10/31 vs 4/46, p = 0.014). The sensitivity of initial CT scan to define borderline resectable disease was worse in the PBD group (91 vs 50%, p = 0.042).
Early surgery to avoid PBD is possible within the NHS. By reducing the time to surgery it appears that more patients undergo potentially curative resection. It is desirable to understand why surgery without PBD is not performed routinely as are the development of strategies to support its more widespread practice.
尽管术前胆道引流(PBD)可能有害,但胰十二指肠切除术(PD)通常仍在术前进行PBD。本研究评估了在英国国民健康服务体系(NHS)框架内避免PBD的途径。
对因壶腹周围癌接受PD的黄疸患者进行前瞻性观察研究。在研究期间开始时引入了一种不进行PBD而提供早期手术的途径。
在12个月内,分别有61例和32例患者接受了有PBD和无PBD的手术;PBD组95%的患者在转诊前已置入支架。无PBD组从CT扫描到手术的时间更短(16天对65天,p<0.0001)。无PBD组接受PD的患者明显更多(31/32对46/61,p=0.009),接受静脉切除的患者也更多(10/31对4/46,p=0.014)。PBD组初始CT扫描对界定边缘可切除疾病的敏感性较差(91%对50%,p=0.042)。
在NHS内避免PBD进行早期手术是可行的。通过缩短手术时间,似乎有更多患者接受了可能治愈性的切除。有必要了解为何不常规进行无PBD的手术,以及支持其更广泛应用的策略的发展情况。