Gafni-Lachter Liat, Admi Hanna, Eilon Yael, Lachter Jesse
Faculty of Social Welfare and Health Sciences, University of Haifa, Haifa, Israel.
Sargent College of Health and Rehabilitation Science, Boston University, Boston, MA, USA.
Work. 2017;57(2):205-210. doi: 10.3233/WOR-172560.
Strikes are means to influence policies related to working conditions, yet raise ethical dilemmas for healthcare workers. Nurse strikes have become more prominent around the world.
To assess the change in Israeli nurses' attitudes towards strikes in light of two physician strikes that have preceded a nursing strike.
An anonymous survey was administered once in 2000 (N = 106) and again in 2011 (n = 175) following 110 days of a physician strike, to assess nurses' attitudes towards the strike and resulting ethical issues.
A statistically significant change (p < 0.05) between administrations revealed that in 2011 more nurses identified striking as a legitimate mechanism, would strike under the same circumstances, and felt that collaboration with physicians persisted despite the strike. Additionally, an increasing number of nurses said that the suffering of patients due to the strike is somewhat or entirely justified, although they were faced with a difficult dilemma of loyalty to physician colleagues vs.
Nurses reported finding ways to mitigate the suffering of patients resulting from the strike.
While patient-centered care remains nurses' first and foremost priority, findings indicate an increasing support of collective bargaining and strike to promote working conditions related to professional and public health agendas.
罢工是影响与工作条件相关政策的手段,但也给医护人员带来了伦理困境。护士罢工在全球范围内变得更加突出。
鉴于在一次护士罢工之前发生的两次医生罢工,评估以色列护士对罢工态度的变化。
在2000年进行了一次匿名调查(N = 106),在医生罢工110天后的2011年又进行了一次(n = 175),以评估护士对罢工及由此产生的伦理问题的态度。
两次调查之间存在统计学上的显著变化(p < 0.05),表明2011年更多护士认为罢工是一种合理机制,在相同情况下会罢工,并且觉得尽管罢工但与医生的合作仍在持续。此外,越来越多的护士表示,罢工给患者带来的痛苦在一定程度上或完全是合理的,尽管他们面临着对医生同事忠诚与对患者忠诚的艰难困境。
护士报告称找到了减轻罢工给患者带来痛苦的方法。
虽然以患者为中心的护理仍然是护士的首要任务,但研究结果表明,越来越多的人支持通过集体谈判和罢工来改善与专业和公共卫生议程相关的工作条件。