Shetty Ajoy Prasad, Viswanathan Vibhu Krishnan, Kanna Rishi Mukesh, Shanmuganathan Rajasekaran
Department of Orthopedics and Spine Surgery, Ganga Hospital, Coimbatore, India.
Spine Fellow, Wexner Medical Centre, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, USA.
Eur Spine J. 2017 Dec;26(12):3178-3186. doi: 10.1007/s00586-017-5157-9. Epub 2017 Jun 7.
(1) To analyze peculiarities of presentation and prognosis of tubercular spondylodiscitis (TBS) in elderly. (2) To assess if associated co-morbidities and risks lead to poorer outcome (3) To observe if different management strategy needs to be implemented in them.
Retrospective analysis of 66 consecutive elderly TBS patients (>60 years) treated conservatively or surgically between January 2010 and July 2013 was performed. Details regarding clinical presentation (general health, ambulatory status, co-morbidities), neurological status, medical or surgical complications and outcome measurements [visual analog score, clinico-radiological evidence of healing and lumbar lordosis in lumbar (L) or lumbo-sacral (LS) or focal kyphosis in thoracic (T) or thoraco-lumbar (TL) disease] were analysed.
Of 66 patients (mean age 67.9 years), 85% had at least one medical co-morbidity and only 45% were community ambulators. Mean delay in presentation was 132 days and lumbar disease was commonest. 35% had neuro-deficit. Most patients had stage 2 (38%) or 3 (42.4%) disease. 19 patients were conservatively managed, while others underwent surgery. Significant complications occurred in 23 patients, most common being liver dysfunction (9 patients). Five patients (8%) expired during treatment: three succumbed to multi-focal tubercular disease, while two expired secondary to medical illnesses. Mean loss of lordosis in conservatively treated (CG) L/LS disease was 8°, while lordosis was restored by 11.6° in operative group (OG). In T/TL disease, sagittal alignment correction by 12.6° was observed in OG as against 5.7° kyphotic collapse in CG patients. 92% patients were cured with no recurrences. The final VAS scores in operative and conservative groups were not significantly different (OG 1.4 ± 0.6, CG 1.9 ± 0.7).
TBS in elderly differed from that in younger by having a higher co-morbidities, later presentation, higher neuro-deficit, greater mortality and increased complications. Nevertheless, in those who survived, clinico-radiological outcomes of both conservative and surgical treatments were good.
(1)分析老年结核性脊椎椎间盘炎(TBS)的临床表现及预后特点。(2)评估合并症及风险因素是否会导致更差的预后。(3)观察是否需要对老年患者实施不同的治疗策略。
对2010年1月至2013年7月间连续收治的66例年龄大于60岁的老年TBS患者进行回顾性分析,这些患者接受了保守治疗或手术治疗。分析了临床表现(一般健康状况、活动状态、合并症)、神经功能状态、内科或外科并发症以及疗效指标[视觉模拟评分、腰椎(L)或腰骶部(LS)疾病愈合的临床影像学证据及腰椎前凸,或胸椎(T)或胸腰段(TL)疾病的局部后凸]。
66例患者(平均年龄67.9岁)中,85%至少有一种内科合并症,仅45%能够在社区活动。平均就诊延迟时间为132天,腰椎疾病最为常见。35%患者存在神经功能缺损。多数患者处于2期(38%)或3期(42.4%)疾病。19例患者接受保守治疗,其余患者接受手术治疗。23例患者发生严重并发症,最常见的是肝功能障碍(9例)。5例患者(8%)在治疗期间死亡:3例死于多灶性结核疾病,2例死于内科疾病。保守治疗组(CG)L/LS疾病患者的腰椎前凸平均丢失8°,而手术组(OG)患者的腰椎前凸恢复了11.6°。在T/TL疾病中,手术组矢状面矫正12.6°,而保守治疗组患者出现5.7°的后凸塌陷。92%的患者治愈且无复发。手术组和保守治疗组的最终视觉模拟评分无显著差异(手术组1.4±0.6,保守治疗组1.9±0.7)。
老年TBS与年轻患者不同,其合并症更多、就诊延迟、神经功能缺损更多、死亡率更高且并发症增加。然而,对于存活患者,保守治疗和手术治疗的临床影像学疗效均良好。