Marx Brian P, Engel-Rebitzer Eden, Bovin Michelle J, Parker-Guilbert Kelly S, Moshier Samantha, Barretto Kenneth, Szafranski Derek, Gallagher Matthew W, Holowka Darren W, Rosen Raymond C, Keane Terence M
The National Center for PTSD, Veterans Affairs Boston Healthcare System.
Research Service, Veterans Affairs Boston Healthcare System.
Psychol Assess. 2017 Jun;29(6):710-719. doi: 10.1037/pas0000378.
This study examined the influence of veterans' race and examiners' use of psychometric testing during a Department of Veterans Affairs posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) disability examination on diagnostic and service connection status outcomes. Participants were 764 veterans enrolled in a national longitudinal registry. Current and lifetime PTSD diagnostic status was determined with the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV (SCID) and was compared with PTSD diagnosis conferred upon veterans by their compensation and pension (C&P) examiners as well as with ultimate Veterans Affairs (VA) PTSD service connected status. The concordance rate between independent SCID current PTSD diagnosis and PTSD disability examination diagnosis was 70.4%, and between SCID lifetime PTSD diagnosis and PTSD disability examination diagnosis was 77.7%. Among veterans with current SCID diagnosed PTSD, Black veterans were significantly less likely than White veterans to receive a PTSD diagnosis from their C&P examiner (odds ratio [OR] = .39, p = .003, confidence interval [CI] = .20-.73). Among veterans without current SCID diagnosed PTSD, White veterans were significantly more likely than Black veterans to receive a PTSD diagnosis from their C&P examiner (OR = 4.07, p = .005, CI = 1.51-10.92). Splitting the sample by use of psychometric testing revealed that examinations that did not include psychometric testing demonstrated the same relation between veteran race and diagnostic concordance. However, for examinations in which psychometric testing was used, the racial disparity between SCID PTSD status and disability exam PTSD status was no longer significant. Results suggest that psychometric testing may reduce disparities in VA PTSD disability exam outcomes. (PsycINFO Database Record
本研究考察了退伍军人的种族以及在退伍军人事务部创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)残疾检查期间检查人员使用心理测量测试对诊断和服役关联状态结果的影响。参与者为764名纳入全国纵向登记处的退伍军人。使用《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第四版(DSM-IV)的结构化临床访谈(SCID)确定当前和终生PTSD诊断状态,并将其与退伍军人的伤残抚恤金(C&P)检查人员给予退伍军人的PTSD诊断以及最终的退伍军人事务部(VA)PTSD服役关联状态进行比较。独立的SCID当前PTSD诊断与PTSD残疾检查诊断之间的一致率为70.4%,SCID终生PTSD诊断与PTSD残疾检查诊断之间的一致率为77.7%。在当前SCID诊断为PTSD的退伍军人中,黑人退伍军人比白人退伍军人从其C&P检查人员处获得PTSD诊断的可能性显著更低(优势比[OR]=0.39,p=0.003,置信区间[CI]=0.20 - 0.73)。在当前SCID未诊断为PTSD的退伍军人中,白人退伍军人比黑人退伍军人从其C&P检查人员处获得PTSD诊断的可能性显著更高(OR = 4.07,p = 0.005,CI = 1.51 - 10.92)。通过使用心理测量测试对样本进行划分后发现,未包括心理测量测试的检查显示退伍军人种族与诊断一致性之间存在相同的关系。然而,对于使用了心理测量测试的检查,SCID PTSD状态与残疾检查PTSD状态之间的种族差异不再显著。结果表明,心理测量测试可能会减少VA PTSD残疾检查结果中的差异。(PsycINFO数据库记录)