Sivaramakrishnan Gowri, Sridharan Kannan
Assistant Professor in Prosthodontics, Department of Oral Health, College of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences, Fiji National University, Suva, Fiji.
Anesth Prog. 2017 Summer;64(2):59-65. doi: 10.2344/anpr-63-03-06.
Nitrous oxide and midazolam have been used as sedative agents to decrease fear and anxiety associated with dental procedures. Although these agents have been widely used individually, the combination of the two is also commonly used. Four clinical trials were identified that compared the combination technique with the individual use of the drugs. The standardized mean difference (SMD) for each outcome measure was considered for final analysis. Three studies with 534 participants were included in the final meta-analysis, and the SMD [95% CI] was obtained as -0.15 [-0.32, 0.03] and was not statistically significant for cooperation scores. Two studies reported the dose of midazolam required for inducing sedation in 450 participants, and the pooled estimate of SMD [95% CI] was obtained as -0.29 [-0.48, -0.10] and was significant. Two studies with 450 participants reported the time taken to recover from sedation, and the pooled estimate of SMD [95% CI] was obtained as -0.20 [-0.39, -0.01] and favored the combination technique. To conclude, the combination technique combines the pros and cons of both drugs in causing fewer adverse effects due to midazolam by reducing the total dose and also helps to provide better acceptance of nitrous oxide inhalation.
氧化亚氮和咪达唑仑已被用作镇静剂,以减少与牙科手术相关的恐惧和焦虑。尽管这些药物已被广泛单独使用,但两者的组合也很常用。已确定四项临床试验,比较了联合使用技术与单独使用药物的情况。最终分析考虑了每个结局指标的标准化均数差(SMD)。三项涉及534名参与者的研究纳入了最终的荟萃分析,合作得分的SMD[95%CI]为-0.15[-0.32,0.03],无统计学意义。两项研究报告了450名参与者诱导镇静所需的咪达唑仑剂量,SMD[95%CI]的合并估计值为-0.29[-0.48,-0.10],具有统计学意义。两项涉及450名参与者的研究报告了从镇静中恢复所需的时间,SMD[95%CI]的合并估计值为-0.20[-0.39,-0.01],支持联合使用技术。总之,联合使用技术结合了两种药物的优缺点,通过减少总剂量减少了咪达唑仑引起的不良反应,并且有助于提高对氧化亚氮吸入的接受度。