Masood U, Cowan T E, Enghardt W, Hofmann K M, Karsch L, Kroll F, Schramm U, Wilkens J J, Pawelke J
OncoRay-National Center for Radiation Research in Oncology, Faculty of Medicine and University Hospital Carl Gustav Carus, Technische Universität Dresden, Fetscherstrasse 74, PF 41, 01307 Dresden, Germany.
Phys Med Biol. 2017 Jul 7;62(13):5531-5555. doi: 10.1088/1361-6560/aa7124.
Proton beams may provide superior dose-conformity in radiation therapy. However, the large sizes and costs limit the widespread use of proton therapy (PT). The recent progress in proton acceleration via high-power laser systems has made it a compelling alternative to conventional accelerators, as it could potentially reduce the overall size and cost of the PT facilities. However, the laser-accelerated beams exhibit different characteristics than conventionally accelerated beams, i.e. very intense proton bunches with large divergences and broad-energy spectra. For the application of laser-driven beams in PT, new solutions for beam transport, such as beam capture, integrated energy selection, beam shaping and delivery systems are required due to the specific beam parameters. The generation of these beams are limited by the low repetition rate of high-power lasers and this limitation would require alternative solutions for tumour irradiation which can efficiently utilize the available high proton fluence and broad-energy spectra per proton bunch to keep treatment times short. This demands new dose delivery system and irradiation field formation schemes. In this paper, we present a multi-functional light-weight and compact proton gantry design for laser-driven sources based on iron-less pulsed high-field magnets. This achromatic design includes improved beam capturing and energy selection systems, with a novel beam shaping and dose delivery system, so-called ELPIS. ELPIS system utilizes magnetic fields, instead of physical scatterers, for broadening the spot-size of broad-energetic beams while capable of simultaneously scanning them in lateral directions. To investigate the clinical feasibility of this gantry design, we conducted a treatment planning study with a 3D treatment planning system augmented for the pulsed beams with optimizable broad-energetic widths and selectable beam spot sizes. High quality treatment plans could be achieved with such unconventional beam parameters, deliverable via the presented gantry and ELPIS dose delivery system. The conventional PT gantries are huge and require large space for the gantry to rotate the beam around the patient, which could be reduced up to 4 times with the presented pulse powered gantry system. The further developments in the next generation petawatt laser systems and laser-targets are crucial to reach higher proton energies. However, if proton energies required for therapy applications are reached it could be possible in future to reduce the footprint of the PT facilities, without compromising on clinical standards.
质子束在放射治疗中可能具有更好的剂量适形性。然而,其庞大的尺寸和高昂的成本限制了质子治疗(PT)的广泛应用。近年来,通过高功率激光系统进行质子加速取得了进展,这使其成为传统加速器颇具吸引力的替代方案,因为它有可能减小PT设施的整体尺寸和成本。然而,激光加速束与传统加速束具有不同的特性,即质子束团非常密集,发散度大且能谱宽。对于激光驱动束在PT中的应用,由于其特定的束参数,需要新的束流传输解决方案,如束流捕获、综合能量选择、束流整形和传输系统。这些束流的产生受高功率激光低重复率的限制,这种限制需要替代的肿瘤照射解决方案,以便能够有效利用每个质子束团可用的高质子注量和宽能谱,从而缩短治疗时间。这就需要新的剂量传输系统和照射野形成方案。在本文中,我们基于无铁芯脉冲高场磁体,提出了一种用于激光驱动源的多功能轻质紧凑型质子龙门架设计。这种消色差设计包括改进的束流捕获和能量选择系统,以及一种新颖的束流整形和剂量传输系统,即所谓的ELPIS。ELPIS系统利用磁场而非物理散射体来拓宽宽能束的光斑尺寸,同时能够在横向方向上对其进行扫描。为了研究这种龙门架设计的临床可行性,我们使用一个3D治疗计划系统进行了治疗计划研究,该系统针对具有可优化宽能宽度和可选束斑尺寸的脉冲束进行了增强。利用这些非常规的束参数,并通过所提出的龙门架和ELPIS剂量传输系统,可以实现高质量的治疗计划。传统的PT龙门架体积庞大,需要很大空间来使束流围绕患者旋转,而所提出的脉冲动力龙门架系统可将所需空间减少多达4倍。下一代拍瓦激光系统和激光靶标的进一步发展对于获得更高的质子能量至关重要。然而,如果达到治疗应用所需的质子能量,未来有可能在不降低临床标准的情况下减少PT设施的占地面积。