Behavioral, Epidemiological & Clinical Sciences Division, FHI 360, 359 Blackwell Street, Suite 200, Durham, NC, 27701, USA.
Health Behavior Department, Gillings School of Public Health, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, USA.
AIDS Behav. 2018 Jan;22(1):245-257. doi: 10.1007/s10461-017-1821-7.
The stages of change (SOC) theory suggests individuals adapt incrementally to behaviors like adherence, requiring different strategies over the behavior change continuum. Offering financial incentives (FIs) is one strategy to motivate adherence. This qualitative sub-study examined adherence barriers and the role of FIs to increase viral suppression (VS) among HIV Prevention Trials Network (HPTN) 065 study participants categorized into SOC-related adherence stages based on changes from baseline to follow-up viral load tests. Of 73 participants, most were in Maintenance stage (n = 31), defined as having achieved VS throughout HPTN 065, or in Action stage (n = 29), defined as moving from virally unsuppressed to suppressed in 50% or more of tests. Only 13 were Low Adherers, having achieved VS in fewer than 50% of tests. The latter group faced substantial social and structural adherence barriers. Participants in the Action stage made positive changes to adherence routines to achieve VS. Those in Maintenance were less incentivized by FIs, as they were already committed. Results from this sub-study suggest FI effectiveness may vary across the SOC continuum, with greatest impact for those initiating antiretroviral or without explicit adherence routines. FIs may be insufficient to overcome strong social or structural barriers, and unnecessary for those intrinsically committed to remaining adherent.
改变阶段(SOC)理论表明,个体逐渐适应依从性等行为,在行为改变连续体上需要不同的策略。提供经济激励(FI)是激励依从性的一种策略。这项定性子研究检查了HIV 预防试验网络(HPTN)065 研究参与者中的依从性障碍和 FI 的作用,这些参与者根据从基线到随访病毒载量测试的变化,按照与 SOC 相关的依从性阶段进行分类。在 73 名参与者中,大多数处于维持阶段(n=31),定义为在 HPTN 065 期间实现了 VS,或处于行动阶段(n=29),定义为在 50%或更多的测试中从病毒未抑制转为抑制。只有 13 人是低依从者,在少于 50%的测试中达到了 VS。后者面临着巨大的社会和结构性依从性障碍。处于行动阶段的参与者对依从性常规做出了积极的改变,以实现 VS。那些处于维持阶段的人对 FI 的激励作用不大,因为他们已经有了承诺。这项子研究的结果表明,FI 的有效性可能会在 SOC 连续体上有所不同,对于那些开始接受抗逆转录病毒治疗或没有明确依从性常规的人影响最大。FI 可能不足以克服强大的社会或结构性障碍,对于那些内在地坚持保持依从性的人来说,FI 是不必要的。