Department Family Medicine, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Department Family Medicine, KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium.
Heart. 2017 Nov;103(21):1727-1732. doi: 10.1136/heartjnl-2016-310905. Epub 2017 Jun 20.
Observational study of patients with chest pain in primary care: determination of incidence, referral rate, diagnostic tests and (agreement between) working and final diagnoses.
118 general practitioners (GPs) in the Netherlands and Belgium recorded all patient contacts during 2weeks. Furthermore, patients presenting with chest pain were registered extensively. A follow-up form was filled in after 30 days.
22 294 patient contacts were registered. In 281 (1.26%), chest pain was a reason for consulting the GP (mean age for men 54.4/women 53 years). In this cohort of 281 patients, in 38.1% of patients, acute coronary syndrome (ACS) was suspected at least temporarily during consultation, 40.2% of patients were referred to secondary care and 512 diagnostic tests were performed by GPs and consulted specialists. Musculoskeletal pain was the most frequent working (26.1%) and final diagnoses (33.1%). Potentially life-threatening diseases as final diagnosis (such as myocardial infarction) accounted for 8.4% of all chest pain cases. In 23.1% of cases, a major difference between working and final diagnoses was found, in 0.7% a severe disease was initially missed by the GP.
Chest pain was present in 281 patients (1.26% of all consultations). Final diagnoses were mostly non-life-threatening. Nevertheless, in 8.4% of patients with chest pain, life-threatening underlying causes were identified. This seems reflected in the magnitude and wide variety of diagnostic tests performed in these patients by GPs and specialists, in the (safe) overestimation of life-threatening diseases by GPs at initial assessment and in the high referral rate we found.
观察初级保健中胸痛患者:发病率、转诊率、诊断检查和(工作与最终诊断之间的)一致性。
荷兰和比利时的 118 名全科医生(GP)在 2 周内记录了所有患者的就诊情况。此外,还详细记录了因胸痛就诊的患者。30 天后填写随访表。
共记录了 22294 例患者就诊。281 例(1.26%)胸痛患者因胸痛就诊(男性平均年龄 54.4 岁/女性 53 岁)。在这 281 例患者中,38.1%的患者在就诊时至少暂时怀疑急性冠状动脉综合征(ACS),40.2%的患者被转诊至二级医疗机构,512 项诊断性检查由全科医生和专科医生进行。肌肉骨骼疼痛是最常见的工作诊断(26.1%)和最终诊断(33.1%)。危及生命的潜在疾病(如心肌梗死)占所有胸痛病例的 8.4%。在 23.1%的病例中,工作诊断和最终诊断之间存在显著差异,在 0.7%的病例中,全科医生最初漏诊了严重疾病。
胸痛患者共 281 例(占所有就诊的 1.26%)。最终诊断大多不危及生命。然而,8.4%的胸痛患者存在危及生命的潜在病因。这似乎反映在全科医生和专科医生对这些患者进行的大量和广泛的诊断性检查、全科医生在初步评估时对危及生命疾病的(安全)过高估计以及我们发现的高转诊率上。