Nakayama Don K
Am Surg. 2017 Jun 1;83(6):660-665.
High salaries indicate a demand for pediatric surgeons in excess of the supply, despite only a slight growth in the pediatric-age population and a sharp increase in numbers of trainees. Top-level neonatal intensive care units require 24-hour-7-day pediatric surgical availability, so hospitals are willing to pay surgeons a premium and engage high-priced locum tenens surgeons to fill vacancies in coverage. With increased supply comes an erosion of the numbers of cases performed by trainees and surgeons in practice. Caseloads may be inadequate to gain expertise and maintain skills. A quality initiative sponsored by the American College of Surgeons and the American Pediatric Surgical Association will discourage underresourced community facilities and surgeons without specialty training from performing operations on children, mostly common conditions such as appendicitis. This will further increase demand for specialty-trained practitioners. Receiving less attention are considerations of value, the ratio of quality per dollar cost. Cost concerns, paramount among buyers of health care (businesses, insurance companies, and governmental health agencies), will prefer community hospitals that have lower cost structures than specialty children's facilities. Less recognized are the costs to families, who for a myriad of reasons would prefer closer alternatives. Cost considerations support providing pediatric surgical services in local facilities. Quality considerations may be addressed by a tiered system where top centers would care for conditions that require technical expertise and advanced modalities. Evidence indicates that pediatric surgeons already direct such cases to more specialized centers.
尽管儿科年龄段人口仅略有增长,且实习医生数量大幅增加,但高薪表明儿科外科医生供不应求。顶级新生儿重症监护病房需要儿科外科医生每周7天、每天24小时随时待命,因此医院愿意向外科医生支付高额报酬,并聘请高价的临时外科医生来填补值班空缺。随着供应增加,实习医生和在职外科医生的手术量逐渐减少。病例数量可能不足以积累专业知识和维持技能。美国外科医师学会和美国儿科外科学会发起的一项质量倡议将不鼓励资源不足的社区医疗机构和未经专科培训的外科医生为儿童做手术,这些手术大多是阑尾炎等常见病症。这将进一步增加对专科培训医生的需求。价值考量,即每美元成本的质量比,受到的关注较少。成本问题在医疗保健购买者(企业、保险公司和政府卫生机构)中至关重要,他们会倾向于成本结构低于专科儿童医院的社区医院。家庭成本则较少被认识到,出于各种原因,家庭更希望选择距离更近的医疗机构。成本考量支持在当地医疗机构提供儿科外科服务。质量考量可以通过分级系统来解决,顶级中心将负责处理需要技术专长和先进治疗方式的病症。有证据表明,儿科外科医生已经将此类病例转诊到更专业的中心。