Giffard Philip M, Su Jiunn-Yih, Andersson Patiyan, Holt Deborah C
Division of Global and Tropical Health, Menzies School of Health Research, Charles Darwin University, Darwin, Northern Territory, Australia.
School of Psychological and Clinical Sciences, Charles Darwin University, Darwin, Northern Territory, Australia.
PeerJ. 2017 Jun 22;5:e3487. doi: 10.7717/peerj.3487. eCollection 2017.
The microbiome of built environment surfaces is impacted by the presence of humans. In this study, we tested the hypothesis that analysis of surface swabs from clinic toilet/bathroom yields results correlated with sexually transmitted infection (STI) notifications from corresponding human populations. We extended a previously reported study in which surfaces in toilet/bathroom facilities in primary health clinics in the Australian Northern Territory (NT) were swabbed then tested for nucleic acid from the STI agents and . This was in the context of assessing the potential for such nucleic acid to contaminate specimens collected in such facilities. STIs are notifiable in the NT, thus allowing comparison of swab and notification data.
An assumption in the design was that while absolute built environment loads of STI nucleic acids will be a function of patient traffic density and facility cleaning protocols, the relative loads of STI nucleic acids from different species will be largely unaffected by these processes. Another assumption was that the proportion of swabs testing positive for STIs provides a measure of surface contamination. Accordingly, "STI profiles" were calculated. These were the proportions that each of the three STIs of interest contributed to the summed STI positive swabs or notifications. Three comparisons were performed, using swab data from clinics in remote Indigenous communities, clinics in small-medium towns, and a single urban sexual health clinic. These data were compared with time and place-matched STI notifications.
There were significant correlations between swab and notifications data for the both the remote Indigenous and regional data. For the remote Indigenous clinics the values ranged from 0.041 to 0.0089, depending on data transformation and value inference method. Further, the swab data appeared to strongly indicate known higher relative prevalence of gonorrhoeae in central Australia than in northern Australia. Similarly, the regional clinics yielded values from 0.0088-0.0022. In contrast, swab and notifications data from the sexual health clinic were not correlated.
Strong correlations between swab and notifications were observed. However, there was evidence for limitations of this approach. Despite the correlation observed with the regional clinics data, one clinic yielded zero positive swabs for , although this STI constituted 25.1% of the corresponding notifications. This could be ascribed to stochastic effects. The lack of correlation observed for sexual health clinic data was also likely due to stochastic effects. It was concluded that toilet/bathroom surface swab sampling has considerable potential for public health surveillance. The approach may be applicable in situations other than primary health clinics, and for targets other than STIs.
建筑环境表面的微生物群落受到人类活动的影响。在本研究中,我们检验了以下假设:对诊所卫生间/浴室的表面拭子进行分析,其结果与相应人群的性传播感染(STI)报告相关。我们扩展了之前报道的一项研究,在该研究中,对澳大利亚北领地(NT)初级保健诊所卫生间/浴室设施的表面进行了拭子采样,然后检测性传播感染病原体的核酸。这是在评估此类核酸污染在此类设施中采集的标本的可能性的背景下进行的。在北领地,性传播感染是需要报告的,因此可以比较拭子数据和报告数据。
设计中的一个假设是,虽然性传播感染核酸在建筑环境中的绝对负荷将取决于患者流量密度和设施清洁规程,但不同物种的性传播感染核酸的相对负荷在很大程度上不受这些过程的影响。另一个假设是,检测出性传播感染呈阳性的拭子比例可衡量表面污染情况。因此,计算了“性传播感染谱”。这些是三种感兴趣的性传播感染中每种感染在性传播感染阳性拭子或报告总数中所占的比例。进行了三项比较,分别使用来自偏远原住民社区诊所、中小城镇诊所和一家城市性健康诊所的拭子数据。这些数据与时间和地点匹配的性传播感染报告进行了比较。
偏远原住民和地区数据的拭子数据与报告数据之间存在显著相关性。对于偏远原住民诊所,根据数据转换和 值推断方法, 值范围为0.041至0.0089。此外,拭子数据似乎强烈表明,澳大利亚中部淋病的相对患病率高于北部。同样,地区诊所的 值为0.0088 - 0.0022。相比之下,性健康诊所的拭子数据与报告数据不相关。
观察到拭子数据与报告数据之间存在强相关性。然而,有证据表明这种方法存在局限性。尽管在地区诊所数据中观察到了相关性,但有一家诊所检测出 的阳性拭子为零,尽管这种性传播感染在相应报告中占25.1%。这可能归因于随机效应。性健康诊所数据缺乏相关性也可能是由于随机效应。得出的结论是,卫生间/浴室表面拭子采样在公共卫生监测方面具有相当大的潜力。该方法可能适用于除初级保健诊所以外的其他情况,以及除性传播感染以外的其他目标。