Elstad Jon Ivar
NOVA, Centre for Welfare and Labour Research, Oslo and Akershus University College of Applied Sciences, Oslo, Norway.
Scand J Public Health. 2018 Feb;46(1):74-82. doi: 10.1177/1403494817705998. Epub 2017 Jun 27.
Health care should be allocated fairly, irrespective of patients' social standing. Previous research suggests that highly educated patients are prioritized in Norwegian hospitals. This study examines this contentious issue by a design which addresses two methodological challenges. Control for differences in medical needs is approximated by analysing patients who died from same causes of death. Area fixed effects are used for avoiding that observed educational inequalities are contaminated by geographical differences.
Men and women who died 2009-2011 at age 55-94 were examined ( N=103,000) with register data from Statistics Norway and the Norwegian Patient Registry. Educational differences in quantity of hospital-based medical care during the 12-24 months before death were analysed, separate for main causes of death. Multivariate negative binomial regression models were estimated, with fixed effects for residential areas.
High-educated patients who died from cancers had significantly more outpatient consultations at somatic hospitals than low-educated patients during an average observation period of 18 months prior to death. Similar, but weaker, educational inequalities appeared for outpatient visits for patients whose deaths were due to other causes. Also, educational inequalities in number of hospital admissions were marked for those who died from cancers, but insignificant for patients who died from other causes.
Even when medical needs are similar for mortally ill patients, those with high education tend to receive more medical services in Norwegian somatic hospitals than patients with low education. The roles played by physicians and patients in generating these patterns should be explored further.
医疗保健应公平分配,不论患者的社会地位如何。先前的研究表明,在挪威医院中,受过高等教育的患者会被优先对待。本研究通过一种解决两个方法学挑战的设计来审视这一有争议的问题。通过分析死于相同死因的患者来近似控制医疗需求的差异。使用地区固定效应来避免观察到的教育不平等受到地理差异的影响。
对2009年至2011年期间年龄在55岁至94岁之间死亡的男性和女性(N = 103,000)进行研究,数据来自挪威统计局和挪威患者登记处的登记资料。分析死亡前12至24个月内基于医院的医疗保健数量的教育差异,按主要死因分别进行。估计多变量负二项回归模型,并对居住地区进行固定效应分析。
在平均18个月的死亡前观察期内,死于癌症的高学历患者在躯体医院的门诊会诊次数明显多于低学历患者。对于死于其他原因的患者,门诊就诊方面也出现了类似但较弱的教育不平等。此外,死于癌症的患者在住院次数上存在明显的教育不平等,但死于其他原因的患者则不显著。
即使重症患者的医疗需求相似,在挪威的躯体医院中,高学历患者往往比低学历患者获得更多的医疗服务。医生和患者在形成这些模式中所起的作用应进一步探讨。