Uittenbroek R J, Kremer H P H, Spoorenberg S L W, Reijneveld S A, Wynia K
* Dit onderzoek werd eerder gepubliceerd in Journal of General Internal Medicine (2017;32:516-23) met als titel 'Integrated care for older adults leads to better quality of care: results of a randomized controlled trial of Embrace'. Afgedrukt met toestemming.
Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd. 2017;161:D1141.
To examine the impact of Embrace (Dutch: SamenOud), a new primary care model for community-living people aged over 75 years on perceived quality of care.
Randomized controlled trial in 15 general practices in the East Groningen region of the Netherlands.
In the period January 2012-March 2013, 1456 general practice patients aged 75 years and older were stratified on the basis of self-reporting into 3 risk profiles: 'robust', 'frail' and 'complex care needs', and then randomized to the intervention or the control arm. Intervention consisted of care and support from an elderly-care team consisting of a specialist in Gerontology, a district nurse, and a social worker. Intensity and duration of the care and support were dependent on risk profile. The primary outcome measure was quality of care as reported by participants; the secondary outcome measure was the extent of implementation as reported by the caregivers.
The level of perceived quality of care after 12 months was slightly higher in the intervention arm than in the control arm, but the effect size was quite small. The difference was significant in elderly people with the risk profiles 'frail' and 'complex care needs'; robust elderly people did not experience a significant difference. The caregivers reported increased implementation of integrated care (effect size 0.71, that means average).
Embrace slightly improved the perceived quality of care, particularly for elderly people with complex care needs for whom case management was organised. Caregivers judged implementation of integrated care to be greatly improved, though there was still room for further improvement. Further research should be carried out into the effectiveness of integrated primary care for the elderly on health, service-use and healthcare costs.
探讨一种针对75岁以上社区居民的新型初级保健模式Embrace(荷兰语:SamenOud)对感知护理质量的影响。
在荷兰东格罗宁根地区的15家普通诊所进行随机对照试验。
在2012年1月至2013年3月期间,1456名75岁及以上的普通诊所患者根据自我报告被分为3种风险类别:“健康”、“虚弱”和“复杂护理需求”,然后随机分为干预组或对照组。干预措施包括由老年病学专家、地区护士和社会工作者组成的老年护理团队提供的护理和支持。护理和支持的强度和持续时间取决于风险类别。主要结局指标是参与者报告的护理质量;次要结局指标是护理人员报告的实施程度。
干预组12个月后的感知护理质量水平略高于对照组,但效应量相当小。在“虚弱”和“复杂护理需求”风险类别的老年人中差异显著;健康的老年人没有显著差异。护理人员报告综合护理的实施有所增加(效应量为0.71,即平均水平)。
Embrace模式略微提高了感知护理质量,特别是对于那些组织了病例管理的有复杂护理需求的老年人。护理人员认为综合护理的实施有了很大改善,不过仍有进一步改进的空间。应进一步研究老年综合初级保健对健康、服务使用和医疗保健成本的有效性。