Lázaro Del Nogal Montserrat, Férnandez Cesareo, Serrano Paloma, Santiago Andrés, Villavicencio Patricia, Martin Teresa
Comisión Contra la Violencia, Hospital Clínico San Carlos, Madrid, España.
Comisión Contra la Violencia, Hospital Clínico San Carlos, Madrid, España.
Rev Esp Geriatr Gerontol. 2018 Jan-Feb;53(1):15-18. doi: 10.1016/j.regg.2017.02.003. Epub 2017 Jun 27.
The Hospital Clínico San Carlos Committee against violence established a protocol in 2012 in order to detect and follow-up violence against elderly persons. This article presents the experience after 3years of its introduction, as well as an analysis comparing the differences between those younger and older than 65years of age.
All cases were collected during years 2013, 2014, and 2015, and were divided into two groups, A and B, according to age, younger or older than 65years. Parameters studied were: gender, place of detection (emergency department, during hospital admission, or outpatient clinics), type of professional worker who detected each case (social workers, nurses, or physicians), previous history of violence, type of aggression (physical, psychological, financial), institutional procedures once aggression was confirmed, and deaths after one year of follow-up. The SPPS v.18.0 package was used for the statistical analysis.
A total of 172 cases were detected, of which 140 of them were included in groupA (<65years), and 32 in groupB (>65 years, 22.8%). Gender: GroupA: women: 93.5%. GroupB: women: 78.1% (P=.014). Registration site: GroupA: emergency department: 90.7%, hospital wards: 6.4%, outpatient wards: 3.0. GroupB: emergency department: 65.6%, hospital wards: 31.6%, outpatient wards: 2.8% (P=.001). Notification: GroupA: social worker: 25%, physician: 67.8%, nurse: 6.4%. GroupB: social worker: 65.2%, physician: 28.1%, nurse: 6.2% (P<.001). Previous violence history: GroupA: 62.1%. GroupB: 68.7%. Type of abuse: GroupA: physical: 56.4%, psychological: 2.8%, physical +psychological: 30.4%, physical +psychological +economic: 10.1%. GroupB: physical: 31.1%, psychological: 5.1%, neglect: 18.7%, physical +psychological: 10.1, physical +psychological +economic: 9.8, economic: 25.1 (P<.0001). Resources employed and follow-up: Injuries: Group A: 63.5%. Group B: 31.2% (P=.001). Judicial protection measures: GroupA: 12.8. GroupB: 15.6 (P=.773). Removal order: GroupA: 2.1. GroupB: 6.25 (P=.235). More than one-third of patients in groupB, and none of the patients in groupA, died in the year of follow-up.
There are more problems detected in the Emergency Department. There is a history of previous violence in more than half of the cases in both age groups. The profile of the victim is an elderly woman with significant physical and cognitive impairment. Economic abuse and neglect are more frequent in the elderly population. In our series, more than one-third of elderly patients who are victims of ill-treatment die each year. The hospital registry is fundamental for the detection and follow-up of abuse in the elderly.
2012年,圣卡洛斯临床医院反暴力委员会制定了一项协议,以检测和跟踪针对老年人的暴力行为。本文介绍了该协议实施3年后的经验,并分析比较了65岁及以下和65岁以上人群之间的差异。
收集2013年、2014年和2015年期间的所有病例,并根据年龄分为A、B两组,65岁及以下为A组,65岁以上为B组。研究的参数包括:性别、发现地点(急诊科、住院期间或门诊)、发现每个病例的专业人员类型(社会工作者、护士或医生)、既往暴力史、攻击类型(身体、心理、经济)、攻击行为确认后的机构程序以及随访一年后的死亡情况。使用SPPS v.18.0软件包进行统计分析。
共检测到172例病例,其中140例纳入A组(<65岁),32例纳入B组(>65岁,占22.8%)。性别:A组:女性占93.5%。B组:女性占78.1%(P=0.014)。登记地点:A组:急诊科占90.7%,医院病房占6.4%,门诊病房占3.0%。B组:急诊科占65.6%,医院病房占31.6%,门诊病房占2.8%(P=0.001)。报告情况:A组:社会工作者占25%,医生占67.8%,护士占6.4%。B组:社会工作者占65.2%,医生占28.1%,护士占6.2%(P<0.001)。既往暴力史:A组占62.1%。B组占68.7%。虐待类型:A组:身体虐待占56.4%,心理虐待占2.8%,身体+心理虐待占30.4%,身体+心理+经济虐待占10.1%。B组:身体虐待占31.1%,心理虐待占5.1%,忽视占18.7%,身体+心理虐待占10.1%,身体+心理+经济虐待占9.8%,经济虐待占25.1%(P<0.0001)。所采用的资源和随访情况:受伤情况:A组占63.5%。B组占31.2%(P=0.001)。司法保护措施:A组为12.8。B组为15.6(P=0.773)。移送令:A组为2.1。B组为6.25(P=0.235)。B组超过三分之一的患者在随访当年死亡,A组无患者死亡。
急诊科发现的问题更多。两个年龄组中超过一半的病例有既往暴力史。受害者的特征是患有严重身体和认知障碍的老年女性。经济虐待和忽视在老年人群中更为常见。在我们的系列研究中,每年有超过三分之一受虐待的老年患者死亡。医院登记对于发现和跟踪老年人受虐待情况至关重要。