Frizelle Pauline, Harte Jennifer, O'Sullivan Kathleen, Fletcher Paul, Gibbon Fiona
Department of Experimental Psychology, Oxford University, Oxford, England.
Department of Speech and Hearing Sciences, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland.
PLoS One. 2017 Jul 3;12(7):e0180496. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0180496. eCollection 2017.
The receptive language measure information-carrying word (ICW) level, is used extensively by speech and language therapists in the UK and Ireland. Despite this it has never been validated via its relationship to any other relevant measures. This study aims to validate the ICW measure by investigating the relationship between the receptive ICW score of children with specific language impairment (SLI) and their performance on standardized memory and language assessments. Twenty-seven children with SLI, aged between 5;07 and 8;11, completed a sentence comprehension task in which the instructions gradually increased in number of ICWs. The children also completed subtests from The Working Memory Test Battery for children and The Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals- 4. Results showed that there was a significant positive relationship between both language and memory measures and children's ICW score. While both receptive and expressive language were significant in their contribution to children's ICW score, the contribution of memory was solely determined by children's working memory ability. ICW score is in fact a valid measure of the language ability of children with SLI. However therapists should also be cognisant of its strong association with working memory when using this construct in assessment or intervention methods.
接受性语言测量中的信息承载词(ICW)水平,在英国和爱尔兰被言语和语言治疗师广泛使用。尽管如此,它从未通过与任何其他相关测量的关系得到验证。本研究旨在通过调查特定语言障碍(SLI)儿童的接受性ICW分数与其在标准化记忆和语言评估中的表现之间的关系,来验证ICW测量。27名年龄在5;07至8;11岁之间的SLI儿童完成了一项句子理解任务,其中指令中的ICW数量逐渐增加。这些儿童还完成了儿童工作记忆测试电池和语言基本要素临床评估-4的子测试。结果表明,语言和记忆测量与儿童的ICW分数之间均存在显著的正相关关系。虽然接受性和表达性语言对儿童的ICW分数都有显著贡献,但记忆的贡献仅由儿童的工作记忆能力决定。ICW分数实际上是SLI儿童语言能力的有效测量方法。然而,治疗师在评估或干预方法中使用这一指标时,也应认识到它与工作记忆的紧密关联。