Ahlqvist Sandra, Björk Dennis, Weisby Lena, Israelsson Leif A, Cengiz Yücel
Department of Anesthesia and Intensive care, Sundsvall Hospital, Sundsvall, Sweden.
Department of Surgery, Sundsvall Hospital, Sundsvall, Sweden.
Surg Technol Int. 2017 Jul 25;30:170-174.
The 5.2% rate of trocar site incisional hernia (TSIH) reported appears low in view of the proportion of TSIH repairs being performed. Detecting TSIH by clinical examination may be difficult in the obese. The correlation between clinical examination and a novel radiological examination for the detection of TSIH in obese patients was studied.
Twenty-six patients subjected to laparoscopic gastric bypass in 2010 underwent clinical and radiological examination by three independent assessors for each method, after a mean follow-up time of 33 months. The computed tomography was in the prone position upon a ring.
At clinical examination, a TSIH was regarded to be present in six out of 26 patients and at CT scan in four. The Fleiss' Kappa for multiple raters was 0.40 (p = 0.184) with clinical examination and 1 (p <0.05) with CT scan. With CT scan, herniation was diagnosed in three of 26 umbilical trocar sites that had been closed at the index operation, and in one of the 130 other trocar sites that had not been closed.
Clinical examination is not reliable when detecting TSIH in the obese. A CT scan in the prone position was extremely reliable and seems to have the potential of becoming the standard method for detecting TSIH in obese patients.
鉴于进行套管针穿刺部位切口疝(TSIH)修复手术的比例,报告的5.2%的TSIH发生率似乎较低。对于肥胖患者,通过临床检查检测TSIH可能较为困难。本研究探讨了临床检查与一种新型放射学检查在肥胖患者中检测TSIH的相关性。
2010年接受腹腔镜胃旁路手术的26例患者,在平均随访33个月后,由三名独立评估者分别采用两种方法进行临床和放射学检查。计算机断层扫描时患者俯卧于环形装置上。
临床检查时,26例患者中有6例被认为存在TSIH,CT扫描时有4例。临床检查时多名评估者的Fleiss' Kappa值为0.40(p = 0.184),CT扫描时为1(p <0.05)。通过CT扫描,在初次手术时已闭合的26个脐部套管针穿刺部位中有3例诊断为疝,在未闭合的其他130个套管针穿刺部位中有1例诊断为疝。
在肥胖患者中检测TSIH时,临床检查不可靠。俯卧位CT扫描极为可靠,似乎有可能成为肥胖患者检测TSIH的标准方法。