Kerkhoff Yvonne R A, Keijsers Noël L W, Louwerens Jan Willem K
1 Department of Orthopaedics, Sint Maartenskliniek, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
2 Research Department, Sint Maartenskliniek, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Foot Ankle Int. 2017 Oct;38(10):1085-1091. doi: 10.1177/1071100717717221. Epub 2017 Jul 14.
Ankle arthrodesis provides satisfactory functional outcome based on basic daily activities, but information regarding more demanding tasks is limited. Also, studies reporting longer term survival and complication rates are sparse and concern small study populations. This study reports functional outcome with more focus on demanding tasks and sports and reports the mid- to long-term union and complication rates in a large study population.
Between 2005 and 2010, an ankle arthrodesis was performed on 185 ankles. Clinical results were retrospectively assessed with the Foot Function Index (FFI), visual analog scale (VAS) for pain, and the Foot and Ankle Ability Measure (FAAM). Information regarding sports pre- and postoperatively was obtained through a questionnaire. In addition, postoperative complications, reoperations, and failures (defined as nonunion of the ankle arthrodesis) were determined. Mean follow-up time was 8 years.
FFI scores significantly improved, the FAAM ADL score was 70%, and the mean VAS for pain at the ankle/hindfoot at follow-up was 20. Sports participation slightly diminished from 79.5% prior to the onset of disabling complaints to 68.9% postoperatively. Of the patients, 73.1% were able to hike with a median hiking time of 40 minutes (range, 2-600 minutes). Kneeling could be performed on average 10 minutes (range, 2-60 minutes) in 39.8% and jumping down from steps by 23.5% of the patients. A small selection of patients was able to sprint (14%), and 16.8% of the patients were able to run a median distance of 60 meters (range, 3-1000 meters). Failure occurred in 9.2% and other postoperative complications were present in 21.6%, requiring reoperation in 8.6% of the cases.
Ankle arthrodesis led to satisfactory functional outcome and pain reduction. Most patients remained active in sports, but a transition to less demanding sporting activities was seen. The complication and failure rates were similar with previous literature, and the incidence of nonrevision secondary surgery was relatively low.
Level III, retrospective comparative study.
基于基本日常活动,踝关节融合术能提供令人满意的功能结果,但关于更具挑战性任务的信息有限。此外,报告长期生存率和并发症发生率的研究较少,且涉及的研究人群规模较小。本研究报告了功能结果,更侧重于具有挑战性的任务和运动,并报告了在一个大型研究人群中的中长期愈合情况和并发症发生率。
2005年至2010年期间,对185例踝关节进行了踝关节融合术。采用足部功能指数(FFI)、疼痛视觉模拟量表(VAS)和足踝能力测量量表(FAAM)对临床结果进行回顾性评估。通过问卷调查获取患者术前和术后的运动信息。此外,确定术后并发症、再次手术和失败情况(定义为踝关节融合术不愈合)。平均随访时间为8年。
FFI评分显著改善,FAAM日常生活活动(ADL)评分达到70%,随访时踝关节/后足疼痛的平均VAS评分为20。运动参与率从出现致残性症状前的79.5%略有下降至术后的68.9%。73.1%的患者能够徒步,徒步时间中位数为40分钟(范围为2至600分钟)。39.8%的患者平均能够跪10分钟(范围为2至60分钟),23.5%的患者能够从台阶上跳下。一小部分患者能够短跑(14%),16.8%的患者能够跑的中位数距离为60米(范围为3至1000米)。9.2%的患者出现失败情况,21.6%存在其他术后并发症,8.6%的病例需要再次手术。
踝关节融合术带来了令人满意的功能结果并减轻了疼痛。大多数患者在运动中仍保持活跃,但出现了向要求较低的体育活动的转变。并发症和失败率与先前文献相似,非翻修二次手术的发生率相对较低。
III级,回顾性比较研究。