Okino Taichi, Kamishima Tamotsu, Lee Sutherland Kenneth, Fukae Jun, Narita Akihiro, Ichikawa Shota, Tanimura Kazuhide
1 Department of Radiological Technology, Sapporo City General Hospital, Sapporo, Japan.
2 Faculty of Health Sciences, Hokkaido University, Sapporo, Japan.
Acta Radiol. 2018 Apr;59(4):460-467. doi: 10.1177/0284185117721262. Epub 2017 Jul 21.
Background Recent papers suggest that finger joints with positive synovial vascularity (SV) assessed by ultrasonography under clinical low disease activity (CLDA) in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients may cause joint space narrowing (JSN) progression. Purpose To investigate the performance of a computer-based method by directly comparing with the conventional scoring method in terms of the detectability of JSN progression in hand radiography of RA patients with CLDA. Material and Methods Fifteen RA patients (13 women, 2 men) with long-term sustained CLDA of >2 years were included. Radiological progression of finger joints was measured or scored using the computer-based method which can detect JSN progression between two radiographic images as the joint space difference index (JSDI), as well as the Genant-modified Sharp score (GSS). We also quantitatively assessed SV of these joints using ultrasonography. Results Out of 270 joints, we targeted 259 finger joints after excluding nine damaged joints (four ankylosis, three complete luxation, and two subluxation) and two improved joints according to the GSS results. The JSDI of finger joints with JSN progression was significantly higher than those without JSN progression ( P = 0.018). The JSDI of finger joints with ultrasonographic SV was significantly higher than those without ultrasonographic SV ( P = 0.004). Progression in JSDI showed stronger associations with ultrasonographic SV than progression in GSS (odds ratio [95% confidence interval]: 7.19 [3.37-15.36] versus 5.84 [2.76-12.33]). Conclusion The computer-based method was comparable to the conventional scoring method regarding the detectability of JSN progression in RA patients with CLDA.
背景 近期论文表明,类风湿关节炎(RA)患者在临床低疾病活动度(CLDA)下通过超声检查评估为滑膜血管(SV)阳性的手指关节可能会导致关节间隙狭窄(JSN)进展。目的 通过直接与传统评分方法比较,研究一种基于计算机的方法在CLDA的RA患者手部X线摄影中检测JSN进展的性能。材料与方法 纳入15例长期持续CLDA超过2年的RA患者(13例女性,2例男性)。使用基于计算机的方法测量或评分手指关节的放射学进展,该方法可检测两张X线图像之间的JSN进展作为关节间隙差异指数(JSDI),以及Genant改良Sharp评分(GSS)。我们还使用超声检查对这些关节的SV进行定量评估。结果 在270个关节中,根据GSS结果排除9个受损关节(4个关节强直、3个完全脱位和2个半脱位)和2个改善关节后,我们将目标定为259个手指关节。发生JSN进展的手指关节的JSDI显著高于未发生JSN进展的手指关节(P = 0.018)。具有超声SV的手指关节的JSDI显著高于无超声SV的手指关节(P = 0.004)。JSDI进展与超声SV的关联比与GSS进展的关联更强(优势比[95%置信区间]:7.19[3.37 - 15.36]对5.84[2.76 - 12.33])。结论 在CLDA的RA患者中,基于计算机的方法在检测JSN进展方面与传统评分方法相当。